The 133rd Legislature convenes Dec. 2 to elect Maine's attorney general through a joint-ballot vote.
“Let the people speak. I trust the people. They elected everyone in this chamber,” Representative David Cotta said during debate on LD 1279, a Republican-backed bill that would have asked voters to amend the Maine Constitution and elect the attorney general, secretary of state and treasurer themselves.
The Maine House rejected the measure 79–59, preserving a system that makes Maine the only state where legislators choose the attorney general.
That vote matters now because the 133rd Legislature convenes December 2 in Augusta, the earliest session start in the nation, and one of its first orders of business is a joint-ballot election for attorney general. Term limits bar incumbent Aaron Frey from running again.
Two Democrats — state Senator Anne Carney and former Yarmouth town councilor Timothy Shannon — are competing for the party’s nomination in caucus meetings before the full Legislature votes. Democrats hold a 114–72 majority across both chambers, meaning their nominee is all but certain to win the 94 votes required for a majority of the 186-seat body.
Maine’s method is an outlier. Attorneys general are directly elected in 43 states, appointed by the governor in five, and chosen by the state supreme court in Tennessee, according to Ballotpedia News. The Maine Constitution requires a joint ballot of senators and representatives at the beginning of each biennium, a practice dating to statehood. The office carries a two-year term and a four-term consecutive limit; Frey has served since 2019.
The Democratic primary has turned on how aggressively the next attorney general should confront the second Trump administration. Shannon, who lost the nomination race in 2018, argues Maine should file its own lawsuits to protect interests unique to the state. “That’s a more thorough undertaking for the office.”
It’s a bigger lift, but it’s potentially a much bigger reward,” he told the Maine Morning Star. Carney, who won re-election to Senate District 29 with 78.5 percent of the vote on November 3, says she would weigh “what is most efficient and effective” before deciding whether to join multistate actions or sue independently.
“This is a moment when Maine needs an attorney general ready to defend our constitutional rights and our state from day one.”
Anne Carney, state senator and candidate for attorney general
Republicans have long pushed to move the selection to the ballot. Representative Andre Cushing sponsored LD 1279, which proposed two-year terms for the treasurer and secretary of state and a four-year term for the attorney general. The Senate blocked it 18–16 a day before the House vote. “How transparent is that? How is that not being influenced by special interests?”
Representative Justin Chenette, a Democrat, asked during the 2011 debate over a similar measure, arguing the current process forces candidates to campaign behind closed doors for legislative votes. Democrats countered that the system produces professional, nonpartisan leadership. “They are staffed by professionals, they are professional in nature. That’s the way we should keep it for the foreseeable future,” Representative Janice Cooper said at the time.
The attorney general’s portfolio is broad. The office oversees the Department of the Attorney General, which operated on a $68.5 million budget for fiscal year 2027, and serves as first in line to succeed the governor — Maine has no lieutenant governor.
The attorney general also appoints deputy and assistant attorneys general and enforces campaign-finance laws through the Maine Commission on Governmental Ethics and Election Practices. Salary is set by the Legislative Council, a ten-member leadership body.
Beyond the attorney general, the December 2 joint session will choose the secretary of state, treasurer and state auditor. Secretary Shenna Bellows and Treasurer Joe Perry, both Democrats, face no opposition. Auditor Matthew Dunlap, also a Democrat, is not up for selection until 2028.
Maine’s early start kicks off a 2027 legislative calendar in which all 50 states will hold sessions. Forty-six legislatures meet annually; Montana, Nevada, North Dakota and Texas convene only in odd-numbered years. The Alaska House and Senate will be governed by bipartisan coalitions. Control of the North Carolina Senate remains uncalled.
Related reading
- Pierre Bouvard Leaves Cumulus Media as Post-Bankruptcy Layoffs Deepen
- Milwaukee Panthers Host St. Thomas in Downtown Opener at UWM Panther Arena
- General Pants enters voluntary administration putting 500 jobs at risk (newsarchyuk.com)
- Dollar General's Four Test Buys: 30 Price Errors, 21 Against the Shopper (daybreakwire.com)