Charitable dollars flow away from the communities that need them most, a pattern that hardens every time the calendar turns to Giving Tuesday.
Research published in Public Administration Review and led by University of Massachusetts Amherst public policy professor Viviana Chiu Sik Wu analyzed county-level data on human-services nonprofits from 2014 through 2019. The study found that economically disadvantaged counties receive significantly less private giving per capita than their better-off peers, even though demand for food banks, homeless shelters and foster-care agencies is demonstrably higher there.
“The communities with the greatest needs are not necessarily the communities receiving the most charitable resources,” Wu said. “And in some cases, government funding can help, but it does not level the playing field everywhere.”
The finding gives fresh weight to the sociological “Matthew Effect” — the idea that advantage begets advantage. In philanthropy, that means communities with existing wealth and fundraising infrastructure attract more donations, while poorer places fall further behind.
On average, a 1% increase in government grants correlated with a 0.03% rise in private donations, the researchers found. The effect was strongest in rural counties, where public dollars appear to signal legitimacy and unlock local giving.
Yet that catalytic link vanished in economically distressed counties. Government support there did not translate into a statistically significant bump in private contributions, suggesting structural barriers — thin nonprofit capacity, fewer local foundations, weaker donor networks — blunt the usual crowding-in effect.
“Government funding can be an important catalyst, but government cannot close these funding gaps alone. Foundations, donors and nonprofit partners also need to invest intentionally in these places.”
Wu said.
The baseline model showed rural counties actually attracted more private giving per capita than urban ones. But Wu cautioned against reading that as health. Rural nonprofits operate with skeletal infrastructure, and rural areas receive lower levels of government spending on human services despite significant need. The per-capita edge may reflect a handful of larger gifts rather than broad-based donor ecosystems.
The research team — Wu, Ji Ma of Indiana University’s O’Neill School, and Chao Guo of the University of Pennsylvania’s School of Social Policy & Practice — recommends long-term, place-based strategies: capacity-building grants, regional partnerships, and funding models tailored to local conditions rather than one-size-fits-all solicitations.
The study was supported by the RGK Center for Philanthropy and Community Service at the University of Texas at Austin and ARNOVA through the RGK-ARNOVA President’s Award.
The University of Massachusetts Amherst, founded in 1863 as the Massachusetts Agricultural College under the Morrill Land-Grant Colleges Act, is the flagship campus of the state’s public university system. It is classified among R1 doctoral universities with very high research activity, reporting $211 million in research and development expenditures in 2018. With roughly 24,000 enrolled undergraduates, it has the largest undergraduate population in Massachusetts.
“Philanthropy does not necessarily flow to communities with the greatest need,” Wu said. “Government support can play a role, but how much really depends on the local context.”