A Maine task force spent more than a year hunting for property tax relief and finished Tuesday with a stack of recommendations — but no agreement on how to pay for the biggest ones.
The 13-member Real Estate Property Tax Relief Task Force, led by Sen. Nicole Grohoski, D-Ellsworth, and Rep. Ann Matlack, D-St. George, voted to send more than a dozen proposals to the Legislature. The ideas range from expanding the state’s two largest relief programs to a controversial levy on high-value second homes that members labeled a “Taylor Swift tax.”
Property taxes have long been a pressure point in Northeast states that lean heavily on them to fund schools, but the pandemic upended valuations and sharpened the squeeze. The task force began its work in September 2025 and issued interim findings in February; its final report is due to lawmakers by Dec. 15.
“I have been consistently supporting looking under every rock and not exempting any rock from consideration as to where to look to help make the property tax situation better for those who are acutely affected, and I’m going to continue to do that,” Grohoski said at the meeting.

Doubling down on the homestead exemption
The clearest consensus formed around the Homestead Exemption, which currently shields up to $25,000 of a primary residence’s value from taxation. The task force unanimously recommended doubling that to $50,000. It also backed expanding the Property Tax Fairness Credit, a refundable credit for lower-income homeowners and renters worth up to $1,000 — or $2,000 for filers over 65 — in the 2025 tax year, according to Maine Revenue Services.
Single filers must earn less than $63,750 to qualify; heads of household and married couples generally must earn less than $82,500. The average credit paid in 2024 was $845, according to the Progress and Poverty Institute, the nonprofit contracted to analyze data for the panel.
The group proposed removing family-size and age restrictions and creating a two-tiered structure: 100 percent reimbursement for taxpayers whose property tax or rent exceeds a certain share of income, and 50 percent for the remainder. It also flagged a persistent awareness gap: only about 72 percent of eligible households claimed the fairness credit and 75 percent claimed the homestead exemption in 2024.
The “critical” program almost nobody uses
The Property Tax Deferral Program lets older adults and homeowners with disabilities defer taxes as a state-backed loan until the home is sold or the owner moves or dies.
“For residents of this state whose home values have greatly appreciated, but who are income-poor and not able to remain current on rising tax bills, this program is a critical tool to help those individuals remain in their homes and communities,” the task force wrote in its draft report.
Yet uptake has been “uniformly and strikingly low.” Of nearly 91,000 eligible households, only 235 are enrolled — a participation rate of 0.26 percent. The panel recommended loosening acreage and liquid-asset limits, adjusting interest rates, allowing eligibility despite existing municipal liens, and requiring towns to include program information with delinquency notices.

A “Taylor Swift tax” splits the room
The sharpest debate centered on a 0.5 percent tax on second homes valued above $1 million. The Progress and Poverty Institute estimated it would raise roughly $50 million annually. Members had previously been told the levy likely violates the Maine Constitution.
The recommendation passed 6–5, couched as a suggestion the Legislature “consider” the idea rather than adopt it outright. Two absent members have until the end of the week to vote, which could alter the final report’s wording.
Maine nonprofits pushed back on a separate proposal to let municipalities charge tax-exempt properties for services such as trash removal, arguing they operate on slim margins with few new revenue options. A companion idea — requiring the state to make payments in lieu of taxes on state-owned land — failed.
The funding hole no one filled
“While it’s more targeted relief for the same money, it’s still raising the mill rates for municipalities,” Portland attorney Phil Saucier said. “The municipalities and the other property taxpayers will be funding these changes, not the state. That’s the problem I have with the funding mechanism part of it.”
Without new revenue, the task force is left reallocating existing dollars. “We’re going to raise just as much from property taxes as we did before. We’re just going to reapportion it a bit in a way that feels a little bit fairer — not a little bit, a lot fairer,” said Dick Woodbury, an economist and former state senator.
“And you know that to me is a good is a pretty amazing accomplishment if we could pull it off.”
Not everyone trusted new taxes to stay dedicated. “The danger of adding new taxes is that they will just become extra money, and it will do nothing to help with the property tax,” said Rep. Robert Nutting, R-Oakland.
The panel did agree on a few revenue raisers: allowing local-option sales or lodging taxes, letting towns charge service fees to tax-exempt properties, and directing the Legislature to find better ways to support service hubs like Bangor and Portland that host hospitals and state offices used by non-residents.
Grohoski, who chairs the task force, grew up in Ellsworth and earned a chemistry and environmental science degree from Middlebury College in 2005 before working as a cartographer. She served two terms in the Maine House representing District 132, then won a June 2022 special election for Senate District 7 and retained the seat that November.
Other recommendations include inventorying municipal impact fees, standardizing assessing standards, studying regionalization, and reviewing underfunded state mandates. The final report heads to the Legislature by Dec. 15.