Utah Lawmakers Unveil Plan to Strip Secrecy From Data Center Deals, Mandate Water Replenishment

Utah lawmakers unveiled a sweeping plan Wednesday to strip secrecy and state-level override power from massive data center deals, a direct response to the political firestorm that toppled a Senate president and cracked a decades-old supermajority.

The framework, presented by Rep. Paul Cutler, R-Centerville, to the Economic Development and Workforce Services Interim Committee, would bar entities like the Military Installation Development Authority from proposing data centers, ban elected officials from signing nondisclosure agreements, and force developers to use closed-loop cooling systems that return water to the Great Salt Lake. Personal property taxes on server hardware would also be earmarked for the lake’s preservation.

“Data centers will happen, but we can make sure that in Utah only the best projects that respect and protect our natural resources that benefit our local communities happen,” Cutler told the Deseret News.

The proposal lands seven months after the Stratos Project — a $100 billion, 40,000-acre development backed by celebrity investor Kevin O’Leary — won fast-tracked approval from MIDA in Box Elder County, igniting a rural revolt that reshaped the state’s political map.

Utah Lawmakers Unveil Proposed Data Center Regulations — FOX 13 News Utah

The Stratos shockwave

When MIDA approved the first phase of Stratos in April, residents in Box Elder County argued they had been cut out of the process entirely. The project, projected to demand up to 9 gigawatts of power at full buildout, became a referendum on transparency and water security in the nation’s second-driest state.

The backlash was electoral. Senate President Stuart Adams, a Stratos supporter, lost his Republican primary in June. In November, Democrats doubled their House seats, shattering the GOP’s supermajority for the first time in 36 years. Utah News Dispatch reported that the blue wave made landfall largely on the strength of data center outrage.

“It’s very clear we have to improve the process,”

Rep. Paul Cutler, R-Centerville, told reporters Wednesday at the state Capitol

Cutler’s framework would return land-use authority to cities, towns, and counties. MIDA and the Utah Inland Port Authority could still offer expertise, but they could not override a local veto. “MIDA can’t override those,” Cutler said during the hearing, responding to a question from Rep. Jim Dunnigan, R-Taylorsville, about whether the authority would retain “super authority.”

Bill mandates closed-loop cooling to protect lake

Water provisions form the framework’s sharpest edge. Traditional evaporative cooling consumes roughly half a gallon per kilowatt-hour; the bill would mandate closed-loop systems that use a fraction of that. Developers would have to purchase water rights, consume less than their allotment, and donate the surplus — along with server hardware tax revenue — to the Great Salt Lake.

“I’ve had a lot of conversations with data center developers, and I’ve had to explain to them that compliance with the law is not a best management practice. So that is just compliance with the law,”

Tim Davis, executive director of the Utah Department of Environmental Quality, said

The framework also targets the tax structure. Under 2020’s S.B. 114, data centers received sales and use tax exemptions. Cutler’s plan would curb or eliminate those incentives, directing the bulk of revenue to the host community for workforce training, utility-rate protection, and infrastructure payback.

Retroactivity remains the open question

Whether the legislation could unwind Stratos is unresolved. Asked if the bill would apply retroactively to the MIDA-approved project, Cutler paused and did not answer directly. “Our intent is to increase local communities’ ability to make their own decisions about whether a data center is appropriate in their community,” he said.

A MIDA spokesperson told Utah News Dispatch the authority “follows the general policy guidelines and specific statutory requirements provided by the legislature.”

Created by the Legislature to preserve Hill Air Force Base, the Military Installation Development Authority operates with just 13 staffers and funds itself solely through tax increment, letting development-generated tax dollars stay inside project areas. That structure drew fresh scrutiny in October 2026 when MIDA classified 100 rooms at the Grand Hyatt in Deer Valley as a military installation, citing their reservation for service members and veterans despite nightly rates near or above $270.

No bill has been filed. Cutler and Sen. Chris Wilson, R-Logan, the Senate’s new majority leader and floor sponsor, will spend the interim gathering public comment and stakeholder input before drafting legislative text. The timeline, Cutler said, “is going to take a while.”