Mandan Voters to Decide Dec. 15 Ban on Large Data Centers, Threatening Stark Power Project

Mandan voters will decide December 15 whether to ban large data centers inside city limits, a special election triggered by more than 700 petition signatures this fall.

The measure would prohibit facilities exceeding 25 megawatts — a threshold that would kill Stark Power’s proposed 300-megawatt campus on the city’s northwest edge, North Dakota Monitor reported. “If city residents vote in favor of the ban, there would be ‘no path forward’ for the project,” Michael Whalen, managing director of digital infrastructure for Stark Power, told a public forum Tuesday night.

Rejecting the ban would not guarantee the project moves ahead; it would only allow Stark Power to submit a formal application and begin the standard permitting and zoning process, Whalen said. The Bismarck Mandan Chamber EDC, which hosted the forum, announced beforehand that its board opposes the prohibition.

“Anytime you put a ban on anything, it takes away the opportunity to have the conversation,” President Brenda Nagel said, adding that a ban could signal to developers in other industries that the area is hostile to investment.

Residents living outside city limits lack voting rights

Jane and Clayton Feist live in the extraterritorial zone up to two miles outside Mandan where the city exercises zoning authority — but they cannot vote in the special election. “We can’t even vote on it even though it affects us,” Jane Feist said.

Clayton Feist worries about standby generators running at odd hours: “Some of us built for retirement. If I try to sell you my home there, and there’s noise, are you going to buy it? I got 16 acres there.”

Mandan Voters to Decide Dec. 15 Ban on Large Data Centers, Threatening Stark Power Project
Photo: yahoo.com

Whalen presented a sound-modeling study from Epsilon Associates showing 45 decibels at the property line and 29 to 39 decibels outside three schools within a mile — levels the American Academy of Audiology equates to a whisper or a quiet library. “It’s not a jet engine,” Whalen said. “It’s a hum.”

Who buys it, and who’s bound by the permits?

Stark Power intends to sell the permitted facility to a hyperscaler — Amazon, Microsoft, Google, or Meta — that would operate the data center. Eden Stramer, who lives about a mile and a half from the site, pressed Whalen on post-sale accountability.

“There are no assurances. You can’t control what the next person does,” she told North Dakota Monitor. Whalen replied that permit conditions bind any future owner: “When another end user takes ownership of the project, they have to adhere to those same conditions or they are subject to revocation of the permit.”

Mandan voters could decide future of large data centers in the city — KFYR+

Economic claims and the city’s caution

The developer projects a $3.4 billion investment across a 300-acre campus on 700 acres, generating $526 million in public revenue over 20 years for schools, parks, and county initiatives, plus a $10 million community-benefit fund at full capacity and $1 million annually thereafter.

Peak construction between 2028 and 2031 would employ more than 1,200 workers; 210 permanent jobs would average roughly $80,000 a year. The closed-loop cooling system would not draw city water, and Stark Power would pay for road upgrades before construction starts.

Mandan’s website notes that no formal application has been filed, so “project-specific benefits or impacts have not been confirmed by city officials.”

Split room, split town

Tom Hansen, a Mandan resident, said he would build it right now and asked why handcuff somebody because you are not 100% sure.

Developer provides updated footprint for Mandan data center
Photo: bismarcktribune.com

Rob Bauer, a Mandan resident, said you hear about all the benefits of having one, and it’s mostly economic, and he doesn’t know of any other benefit than the economic one. He said he still doesn’t think there’s enough information to go forward with it.

The city was founded in 1879 when the Northern Pacific Railroad platted “Mandan Proper” on the west bank, taking its name from the historic Mandan people whose villages — including Good Fur Robe at the base of Crying Hill — dotted the riverbank for centuries before Lewis and Clark passed through in 1804 and 1806.

Absentee ballots are available from the city; in-person voting runs 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. December 15 at Spirit of Life Roman Catholic Church, 801 First St. SE.