Mayo Clinic’s Rochester flagship took in $366 million more in tax breaks than it spent on charity care in 2023, the largest gap of any nonprofit hospital in the country, Minnesota Reformer reported from a Lown Institute analysis released this week.
The think tank reviewed 2023 tax filings, Medicare cost reports, and local property assessments for roughly 3,000 hospitals. Half of all nonprofit hospitals nationwide received more in tax exemptions than they returned in financial assistance and community investment, but Mayo’s shortfall dwarfed the next closest Minnesota offender — HealthPartners’ Methodist Hospital in St. Louis Park — by a factor of seventeen.
“The methodology excludes important categories of Community Benefit identified by the IRS, including Medicaid shortfall, medical research and health professions education.”
a Mayo Clinic spokesperson said in a statement disputing the findings as “deeply flawed.”
The AG investigation that preceded the numbers
The Lown snapshot captures 2023, a year after the Minnesota Attorney General’s Office opened an investigation triggered by Rochester Post Bulletin reporting that Mayo had sued patients who qualified for free care. Investigators found the system instructed staff not to mention charity programs and used an application process so cumbersome that eligible patients gave up.

Mayo doubled its charity spending between 2022 and 2024, after the probe began. A 2025 settlement now requires streamlined applications and automatic qualification for some patients — changes that fall outside the Lown study window.
High commercial prices swell revenue
Context sharpens the contrast. In 2022, Mayo charged private insurers more than four times the Medicare rate for outpatient procedures, the same Minnesota Reformer story noted. High commercial prices swell revenue, which expands the tax-exemption value the Lown model measures, while the charity-care denominator — measured at cost — barely moves.
A joint KFF Health News and Star Tribune investigation published earlier this year found Minnesota hospitals overall give less financial aid as a share of operating budgets than peers in almost every other state.

IRS counts Medicaid shortfalls as community benefit
The dispute hinges on definition. The IRS allows hospitals to claim Medicaid shortfalls, research spending, and physician training as “community benefit” to justify tax-exempt status. Lown deliberately omits those categories, arguing they do not represent direct financial relief for patients who cannot pay.
Mayo contends its research and training pipelines ultimately lower costs and improve care for everyone. The think tank counters that the trade-off is opaque and that patients facing collection lawsuits today cannot wait for tomorrow’s breakthroughs.
The Attorney General’s settlement runs through 2028; compliance reports are due annually.