Michigan Democrats Urge Whitmer to Reject Federal Scholarship Tax Credit Program

Forty-nine Democratic lawmakers in Lansing sent a letter to Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Wednesday urging her to keep Michigan out of a new federal scholarship tax credit program before a Jan. 1 opt-in deadline.

The letter, led by outgoing state Rep. Regina Weiss of Oak Park, argues that participating in the Education Freedom Tax Credit program — created under President Donald Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act — would risk the historic education investments Michigan has made since 2019.

Those investments include expanded funding for economically disadvantaged students, students with disabilities and English language learners; universal free breakfast and lunch; expanded early childhood access; stronger literacy instruction; and new money for educator recruitment, retention and student mental health services.

“Michigan has made tremendous progress in public education by investing in our students, supporting our educators and working to ensure every child has access to the resources they need to succeed,” Weiss said.

“We cannot afford to put that progress at risk by diverting public resources toward a federal program that lacks sufficient transparency and accountability. Our responsibility should be to strengthen our neighborhood public schools, not create new systems that could undermine them.”

The federal Education Freedom Tax Credit allows residents to make tax-deductible donations to public or private schools and receive up to a $1,700 tax credit in return. Schools could use the funds for scholarships or services such as tutoring. Critics, including the lawmakers who signed the letter, describe it as a roundabout way to funnel public money to private schools — effectively a voucher program by another name.

Michigan Democrats Urge Whitmer to Reject Federal Scholarship Tax Credit Program
Photo: yahoo.com

When asked Wednesday whether the program amounted to vouchers, Whitmer acknowledged the argument. “I understand some people have made that argument,” she told reporters in Lansing. “There are a lot of Democratic states that have gone forward with it. I think we’re looking to the Attorney General for interpretation on the Michigan Constitution, etcetera. A lot of information yet to be gleaned.”

Whitmer’s administration has delayed a decision, joining other governors in requesting more guidance from U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. “We’re taking a look at it,” she said. “We were waiting for the [Department of] Treasury guidance; now we’ve got it, we’re taking a look. I take it seriously. I want to make sure we have thought through everything.”

Business groups push the other way

Not everyone in Lansing wants Whitmer to say no. The Detroit Regional Chamber and the Grand Rapids Chamber both sent letters this month urging the governor to opt in before the deadline.

“Michigan taxpayers can claim this federal tax credit whether Michigan opts in or not,” Detroit Regional Chamber CEO Sandy Baruah wrote on Nov. 3. “The question is whether those dollars support education in our state, or if Michigan parents and grandparents select to access this tax credit by supporting educational establishments elsewhere.”

Michigan Democrats Urge Whitmer to Reject Federal Scholarship Tax Credit Program
Photo: arcamax.com

The chambers argue that opting out simply sends Michigan tax dollars to other states without benefiting local schools.

Election results shape program's uncertain future

The lawmakers’ letter leans heavily on the November election results. Voters rejected Republican gubernatorial candidate U.S. Rep. John James, who had promised to opt Michigan into the program “from day one.” Democratic Gov.-elect Jocelyn Benson has already declared her opposition, calling it “a program under Trump’s control with zero transparency or assurance it will deliver for Michigan students.”

Weiss and her colleagues also point to a practical problem: the program could be repealed within two years if Democrats retake the White House and Congress in 2028.

“It makes little sense to undertake such a significant investment in new infrastructure and administrative systems for a federal program that could be repealed within two years,” the letter says. “Michigan should not create unnecessary costs, uncertainty, or disruption for our public schools to accommodate a policy with such an uncertain future.”

Instead of building that infrastructure, the lawmakers want Whitmer to join them in demanding Congress repeal the tax credit provision and finally fulfill the federal government’s 50-year-old commitment to fund 40 percent of special education costs under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.

“Michigan should be focused on building on the progress we’ve made, not creating uncertainty for the future of our public schools,” Weiss said. “We should be demanding that the federal government meet its obligations to our students, particularly students with disabilities, instead of embracing a program that could pull our attention and resources away from the schools that serve the vast majority of Michigan children.”

Outgoing state Rep. Regina Weiss, born in Chicago in 1986, taught high school English and social studies in the Detroit Public Schools Community District and served on the Oak Park City Council from 2017 to 2020 before winning election to the Michigan House in 2020. She was reelected with over 83% of the vote in 2022 and won again in the redrawn 5th district in 2024, but announced this year she will not seek a fourth term.

Whitmer has not set a public timeline for her decision beyond the Jan. 1 deadline.