Michigan State took the field Friday night with a roster decimated by injuries and quarterback instability.
The Spartans have remained in nearly every game deep into the fourth quarter despite a talent floor that has collapsed week after week.
The disconnect is the story. On tape, Michigan State looks fundamentally sound — disciplined in its fits, structured in its coverages, competitive on every snap. The offense cannot finish drives when the defense gets stops; the defense, gassed and undermanned, cannot make one last stand in the final minutes.
Average injury luck makes this a bowl team. Good luck might have yielded a signature win over Notre Dame and eight victories. The Spartans play out the string on Senior Night against Oregon.
“The hard luck at Michigan State has been astonishing,” the Addicted To Quack analysis noted, framing a season where the variable wasn’t scheme but availability.
The quarterback carousel
Starter Aiden Chiles was benched in 2025 for Milivojevic, who posted a passer rating half a standard deviation better on comparable attempts. Chiles transferred to Northwestern.
Milivojevic entered 2026 as the guy, but a recurring UCL sprain on his throwing thumb and constant pocket breakdowns — driven by offensive-line mismanagement during the coaching transition — forced a parade of replacements. His error rate on charted dropbacks stayed low; the throwaways were smart football that killed his stat line.
Sixth-year senior Fancher operated as a change-of-pace runner and occasional series relief until a violent hit against Wisconsin in Week 5 sidelined him for six weeks. True freshman Coffman absorbed garbage-time snaps against the Badgers, then started against UCLA when Milivojevic’s thumb flared again.
Coffman exited mid-third quarter after a sack rattled him and UCLA edge rusher Ryan McCullough. Redshirt freshman Hannan finished the game — 21 meaningful plays over the final two quarters — becoming the fourth quarterback to see action.
Milivojevic returned for the rivalry win over Michigan wearing a protective sheath, then lasted a half against Washington before a linebacker de-cleated him on a scramble. Fancher, cleared to return, finished the game save for a three-and-out by Coffman after Fancher briefly dinged his arm throwing the ball away on a sack-escape that became an interception.
On the availability report for Friday, Milivojevic is out. Fancher is questionable. Addicted To Quack’s podcast partner Jonathan Schopp, contributor emeritus to Spartan Nation, argued there is no upside to playing Milivojevic with bowl eligibility gone; the staff will honor seniors Friday, then pivot to youth at Rutgers next week for evaluation.
If Fancher plays, the sixth-year senior starts. If not, Coffman gets the nod, though the analyst confessed a preference for Hannan’s arm talent on the limited tape available.
A receiving corps without a ceiling
Redshirt freshman Savoury, a former basketball player new to football, emerged as the second-most targeted pass catcher on the team before a late catch against UCLA ended his season. Parachek, a highly rated 2023 recruit who lost his spot to Jack Veling under the previous staff and took an injury redshirt last year, managed only 10 targets with poor blocking grades and is questionable.
Rios steps into the primary role in 12-personnel sets — offensive coordinator Sheridan is a former tight-end coach — but without Savoury’s field-stretching ability, the unit projects as a possession-only group averaging under 5.0 yards per play. Fullback-by-trade Gulker, listed as a tight end, offers 2.8 yards per touch on dive plays.

At receiver, slot man McCray — a former two-star Kent State transfer — leads the room with a 52.8% success rate and 7.27 adjusted yards per target, numbers that lag FBS medians for a WR1 regardless of quarterback. The bottom four young receivers — Collier, Gash, KK Smith, Taplin — combine for 13 meaningful targets but a 64.3% success rate and 9.54 yards per target.
Michigan transfer F. Moore, the only reliable outside target at 6’1″, posts a 60% success rate on 7.29 yards per target and deserves a 50% target increase by any rational distribution. Bullard, a Division II transfer acquired via court battle, sits underwater at 48.7% success and 6.39 yards per target.
Schopp and the analyst hold a prop bet on whether the freshmen see the field at Rutgers. The expectation: McCray starts and absorbs the volume Friday night.
The administrative fog
The analysts circled the topic on podcasts but declined to resolve it without more information, treating it as background noise to the on-field evaluation.
Oregon faces a fundamentally sound opponent missing its best players, starting a quarterback likely to be Fancher or Coffman behind a line allowing constant pocket breakdowns, throwing to receivers who cannot separate, facing a defense that has played competitively only to watch leads slip away. The tape says Michigan State is well coached.
“This same Spartans team with average injury luck is likely a bowl team,” the analysis concluded.
Related reading
- Hartford Organizations Offer Free Thanksgiving Meals and Turkeys
- Augusta Design Society Gains 501(c)(3) Status to Connect Region’s Designers
- Fiji Declares National State of Disaster Over Worsening El Niño Drought (world-today-news.com)
- Scotland captain Rory Darge ruled out of Japan match with injury (newsarchyuk.com)