Michigan Supreme Court Declines Appeal on Clean Energy Zoning Law, Sets 2027 Arguments

The Michigan Supreme Court on Friday declined to hear an appeal from 79 local governments challenging the state’s authority to override restrictive zoning rules for large wind, solar and battery projects, effectively keeping the permitting pathway open under Public Act 233.

The court denied leave to appeal “because we are not persuaded that the question presented should be reviewed by this Court,” Michigan Advance reported.

The decision marks a legal dead end for the remaining claims that the Michigan Public Service Commission overstepped when it wrote the rules implementing the Clean Energy and Jobs Act, which Gov. Gretchen Whitmer signed in 2023. But the justices agreed to review two narrow procedural issues raised in a cross-appeal by the commission and clean-energy intervenors, setting oral arguments for January 2027.

What the ruling leaves intact

Public Act 233 gives developers of utility-scale renewable projects — solar arrays, wind farms and battery storage projects over certain size thresholds — a route to state-level permitting when local rules are stricter than state standards, when a local decision drags past statutory deadlines, or when a compliant project is denied. The Public Service Commission issued its implementing order on October 10, 2024, just before the law took effect.

In May, the Michigan Court of Appeals upheld most of that order but struck two provisions. It ruled the commission erred by limiting the definition of “affected local unit” to only those governments with zoning authority, and it said the commission’s timeline for notifying developers about “compatible renewable energy ordinances” did not match the statute.

The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the localities’ broader appeal leaves those appellate corrections in place while preserving the core state-permitting framework.

Michigan Supreme Court Declines Appeal on Clean Energy Zoning Law, Sets 2027 Arguments
Photo: iosconews.com

“Michigan needs to generate more energy to keep energy costs down as demand continues to surge. The Clean Energy and Jobs Act ensures business leaders have certainty to invest in Michigan, building the projects that power the state’s grid and create jobs.”

said Trish Demeter, senior managing director at Advanced Energy United, one of three industry groups that intervened in the case. The Michigan Energy Innovation Business Council and Clean Grid Alliance joined the statement applauding the denial.

Counties claim a partial win on jurisdiction

The law firm representing the townships and counties, Foster Swift Collins & Smith, PC, framed the outcome differently. Michael D. Homier, leader of the firm’s municipal practice group, emphasized that the Court of Appeals ruling on “affected local unit” survives.

“This is an important win for counties and other local governments that may not exercise zoning authority over a project site but will nevertheless experience the project’s impacts.”

Homier said. “The decision confirms that those communities cannot be excluded from the rights and protections the Legislature provided under PA 233 simply because another local government exercises zoning jurisdiction.”

Michigan Supreme Court Declines Appeal on Clean Energy Zoning Law, Sets 2027 Arguments
Photo: yahoo.com

The Michigan Public Service Commission said that 13 projects — mostly solar farms — have already applied for state approval under the new rules. In August, regulators approved a settlement allowing a 600-acre solar farm in Ingham County to proceed, calling the law “a law that is working as intended.”

The Supreme Court ordered the Clerk to schedule oral arguments for January 2027 on the two cross-appeal questions: the notification timeline for compatible ordinances and whether a developer can move forward when local officials do not respond to a meeting request within 30 days or never hold the meeting at all. The commission said it “look[s] forward to making our case.”

For now, the state permitting pathway remains active, and the January arguments will shape how two procedural guardrails function in practice.