The town of Milton, Massachusetts, has faced intense scrutiny after local reporting revealed its school district hired off-duty police officers to conduct residency checks and surveillance on children suspected of living outside town boundaries, with the majority of those investigations targeting African-American students.
State law empowers school districts to carry out residency surveillance and remove students who live outside municipal lines. This enforcement stems from a traditional system that assigns children to public schools strictly based on their home address.
The Boston Globe first uncovered the surveillance program in Milton, detailing how off-duty officers were brought in to investigate student residency. The reporting sparked widespread public debate over the tactics used and the demographic breakdown of the targeted families.
Surveillance Near Mattapan
Many of the residency checks took place near Tucker Elementary, located blocks from the predominantly African-American Boston neighborhood of Mattapan. Families in Mattapan often look outside their immediate neighborhood for better educational opportunities because local options struggle academically.

Academic performance data highlights the disparities driving these family decisions. At Tucker Elementary, 54% of students read at grade level, while at Chittick Elementary School, located less than a mile away, only 21% of children read at grade level.
The Reason Foundation gave Massachusetts an F grade for its public school open enrollment laws last year. The rating reflects a Bay State framework that relies heavily on a child’s address and gives districts the discretion to opt out of cross-district open enrollment.
Addressing Systemic Barriers
Massachusetts school districts face no requirement to publish data regarding available open seats, and families have no formal appeals process if a transfer request is denied. These policies contrast sharply with the legacy of Horace Mann, the Massachusetts education reformer who envisioned public schools as a universal equalizer.
Critics argue that strict residency enforcement criminalizes parents who simply want access to better academic environments. A previous report titled When Good Parents Go to Jail documented cases where parents faced prosecution and imprisonment under similar laws.
Alternative models exist in states like Arizona and Wisconsin, where districts must admit out-of-district children if space is available, and state funding follows the student. Without similar reforms, critics contend that Massachusetts public schools will remain closed in practice to families priced out of affluent neighborhoods.