A Milwaukee County jury returned guilty verdicts on all seven counts Thursday against Thomas Seville Zollicoffer in the August shootings that killed three people.
Zollicoffer, who was arrested three days after the killings following an hour-long standoff near 84th Street and Fiebrantz Avenue, was convicted of three counts of first-degree intentional homicide and four counts of possession of a firearm by a felon. Each homicide conviction carries a mandatory life sentence in Wisconsin.
Sentencing is set for Friday at 9 a.m. before Milwaukee County Judge David Borowski, who said he would clear his calendar to impose the sentence. The judge will also decide whether Zollicoffer ever becomes eligible for extended supervision.
“That is exactly what I’m saying,” Zollicoffer told the prosecutor on cross-examination when asked if his earlier confession to police had been a lie.
The verdict capped a dramatic conclusion in which Zollicoffer took the stand in his own defense and offered a version of events that contradicted his own recorded police interview. In that interview, he told a detective he shot DeHerrera in the head; on the stand, he claimed he had lied to detectives because he felt guilty.

According to Zollicoffer’s testimony, DeHerrera was shot during a struggle over a gun with Bucholz at a home near 21st and Pierce streets. He also acknowledged shooting Hare at a second home near 39th and Townsend streets, telling jurors that Hare grabbed him before he fired, though he acknowledged on cross-examination that he did not see Hare with a weapon.
The Wisconsin State Crime Laboratory firearms examiner testified that the 9 mm Taurus at the center of the case fired cartridge casings recovered from both homicide scenes, as well as bullets recovered from DeHerrera and Hare. A DNA analyst also testified about DNA recovered from the weapon.
Tension flared after jurors left the courtroom. Zollicoffer asked the judge to lift restrictions on his communications; after Borowski denied the request, stating there was “no doubt in his mind” that Zollicoffer would contact and harass the victims’ families, Zollicoffer responded with a string of expletives directed at the judge.
Milwaukee County, the state’s most populous and densely packed county, held 939,489 residents in 2020 and accounts for about 15% of Wisconsin’s population. Created in 1834 as part of Michigan Territory, it once encompassed much of southeastern Wisconsin before being reduced to its present boundaries in 1846. Uniquely among Wisconsin counties, it is completely incorporated, containing 19 municipalities but no unincorporated towns. The county is also home to Summerfest, the world’s largest music festival.
In August, Zollicoffer shot his ex-girlfriend, 26-year-old Vanessa DeHerrera, and her friend, 29-year-old Scott Bucholz, at a party before shooting Shamarla “Asir” Hare later that evening.
