Milwaukee Man Sentenced to Three Consecutive Life Sentences With No Chance of Release

Milwaukee County Judge David Borowski sentenced Thomas Seville Zollicoffer to three consecutive life sentences with “no chance whatsoever” to be considered for release Friday, closing a case that began with three killings across the city in less than half an hour on Aug. 8.

The sentence ensures Zollicoffer, 37, will die in prison for the murders of his ex-girlfriend Vanessa DeHerrera, 26, her friend Scott Bucholz, 29, and Shamarla Hare, 39 — a penalty Borowski framed in unsparing terms. "You can be as evil as this defendant, but you can't be more evil," the judge said from the bench, repeatedly calling Zollicoffer a "monster" and invoking the Darrell Brooks case to emphasize the gravity of the offenses, FOX6 News Milwaukee reported.

Zollicoffer offered no mitigation. “Give me the life sentence,” he told Borowski before the ruling. The request came after a jury convicted him Thursday on all counts: three counts of first-degree intentional homicide and four counts of possession of a firearm by a felon.

Thomas Zollicoffer sentencing; convicted of killing 3 in Milwaukee — FOX6 News Milwaukee

The night the trail began

Prosecutors laid out a timeline that moved with terrifying speed. Around 9 p.m. on Aug. 8, Zollicoffer arrived at an apartment near 21st and Pierce streets and shot DeHerrera and Bucholz. Less than 30 minutes later, he appeared at a home near 39th and Townsend and killed Hare, according to the criminal complaint detailed by FOX6 News Milwaukee.

Witnesses inside the second residence described a scene of calculated violence. Pat Carter, a friend of Hare, testified that Zollicoffer entered and announced, “Listen, I got something to tell y’all.”

When Hare challenged him, Carter said, Zollicoffer pulled a gun and shot her multiple times. Pamela Carter, another witness, told jurors through tears that Zollicoffer stood over Hare and fired again into the top of her head before leaving, TMJ4 News reported.

Victim's family speaks out as Thomas Zollicoffer pleads not guilty in triple murder case
Photo: tmj4.com

Before fleeing, Zollicoffer told those present he had already killed his child’s mother — a reference to DeHerrera — according to trial testimony cited by TMJ4 News.

Driver testifies Zollicoffer admitted killings during ride

The state’s case hinged heavily on Sengchanh Phengphonsavanh, 47, who drove Zollicoffer between the two crime scenes. Phengphonsavanh testified that Zollicoffer called him around 9 p.m. requesting a ride from 21st and Pierce. During the drive to 39th and Townsend, Phengphonsavanh said Zollicoffer phoned someone and stated he had “dropped four bodies” and killed DeHerrera.

FULL Sentencing: Thomas Seville Zollicoffer sentenced by Judge David Borowski — FOX6 News Milwaukee

Phengphonsavanh waited in the car, heard gunshots, and saw Zollicoffer return. “I was scared he would come back and harm my family,” Phengphonsavanh told the court when asked why he did not flee, according to TMJ4 News. He later drove Zollicoffer toward 71st Street and Silver Spring Drive after Zollicoffer threw his cellphone from the vehicle near 50th and Capitol streets.

Phengphonsavanh pleaded guilty to harboring a felon on Nov. 16 as part of a plea agreement requiring his testimony, court records show.

Thomas Zollicoffer sentencing: Victims' families share emotional statements — FOX6 News Milwaukee

Days after the shootings, police located Zollicoffer at his cousin’s home near 84th and Fiebrantz. During the standoff, authorities recovered a handwritten note addressed to DeHerrera.

Detective Paul Martinez read it aloud in court: “Vanessa, first off I love you, but I’m not sorry. I warned you to stop playing with me and you did anyway. I hate my actions, but I forgive myself and I will see you in the afterlife. Mom, you are my world, my world.” Martinez acknowledged on cross-examination that the note was undated, TMJ4 News reported.

Cases still open

Two co-defendants await resolution. Elana Cole, 38, Zollicoffer’s cousin, is charged with harboring/aiding a felon and three misdemeanors; she pleaded not guilty in October, and a deferred prosecution agreement hearing is scheduled for December, according to FOX6 News Milwaukee. Phengphonsavanh’s sentencing has not yet been set.

Zollicoffer trial recap: Milwaukee man found guilty of 3 homicides — FOX6 News Milwaukee

“You can be as evil as this defendant, but you can’t be more evil.”

Judge David Borowski, Milwaukee County Circuit Court

The three mothers of the victims addressed the court Friday before sentencing, their statements forming the emotional core of a hearing that lasted hours. Borowski’s reference to the Brooks case — the Waukesha Christmas parade attacker sentenced to life without release — signaled the court’s view that this spree occupied the same moral tier.

Zollicoffer’s conviction and sentence bring finality to the homicide counts, but the ripples extend to the two remaining dockets and to the families who sat through weeks of testimony. The next dated event on the record is Cole’s hearing in December.