The Minneapolis City Council failed Friday to override Mayor Jacob Frey’s veto of its rejection of Bill Peterson as police chief, leaving the interim chief’s nomination alive and headed for a second confirmation vote.
The override effort fell 7–5, two votes short of the nine required. The council had voted 8–5 last week to deny Peterson the permanent post after a marathon hearing that exposed deep fractures over department culture, accountability, and the legacy of George Floyd’s murder.
Frey vetoes denial; council override attempt fails
Frey vetoed the denial Thursday, arguing the next chief “should be judged, not on where a department has been, but where the candidate will take it,” according to his veto letter.
He wrote that voting Peterson down because council members “have a different real or hypothetical idea of a candidate, has no bearing on the actual question in front of them, which is whether Interim Chief Billy Peterson is qualified for the job. To that question, there is only one honest answer: yes.”
Friday’s override attempt mirrored the original confirmation tally almost exactly: five members supported Peterson, seven opposed him, and Council Member Jamison Whiting was absent. The same 7–5 split doomed a separate override attempt on Frey’s veto of a new data-center ordinance, leaving both of the mayor’s vetoes intact.
Why the council said no the first time
Last week’s confirmation hearing ran for hours. Council members pressed Peterson, a 31-year department veteran, on racist language used by officers, use-of-force incidents, homelessness, and the budget. Council Member Soren Stevenson, who was shot by a “non-lethal” projectile from an MPD officer while protesting in 2020, asked directly about police violence.
“I can tell you that over the course of my career, I have earned a reputation as somebody who does not tolerate nonsense around me. … If and when incidents come across my desk, whether it’s use-of-force or any other allegation against members of the Minneapolis Police Department, I take them very seriously,” Peterson told the council.
Minneapolis City Council rejects appointment of interim police chief Bill Peterson In a surprising turn on Thursday, a majority of the 13 members of the Minneapolis City Council voted against Mayor Jacob Frey's nomination of interim police chief Bill Peterson to become the… pic.twitter.com/XyKMf7igpV
Two internal complaints against Peterson remain open, though details have not been made public. Council Member Pearll Warren said those complaints drove her no vote. “I like you as a person, you know. I respect your work ethic. I respect your servitude, but that is something that is deeply important to me, especially in the fragility of leadership that we have before us in this city,” Warren said last week.
“This does not have absolutely anything to do with anything else but that.” Peterson acknowledged awareness of the complaints but said he had little knowledge of the specific incidents.
Frey’s case for an insider
The mayor has consistently argued that community listening sessions showed residents want an internal candidate who knows what the city has “been through.” Frey also pointed to the department’s ongoing federal consent decree and state enforcement agreement as reasons to keep a leader already versed in the reform mandates.

Peterson initially said he did not want the permanent job but changed his mind after discussions with his family. He was named interim chief in May after former Chief Brian O’Hara resigned suddenly.
Frey vetoes data-center ordinance; council considers override
The same council session took up Frey’s veto of a data-center ordinance the council had passed 7–6. The compromise policy would have created two downtown districts and given council members the power to allow or deny specific developments. Frey called the zoning standards “confounding” and warned they would create “inconsistent rules” and “lead to arbitrary rule making.”
“We have an opportunity to provide an important regulatory framework, embrace economic progress, and alleviate a tax burden for our residents,” Frey said in his veto message.
Frey may renominate Peterson for future council vote
Frey can now renominate Peterson, and the council will vote again on his confirmation at a future meeting. No date has been set.
Mayor Frey's pick to be the next police chief, Billy Peterson, rejected by Minneapolis City Council. 8-5 vote against.