Mississippi Appeals Court Overturns Edwards’ Murder Conviction, Orders New Trial

A Mississippi appeals court has overturned the murder conviction of William “Polo” Edwards, ordering a new trial because his right to counsel was violated.

The ruling, issued Tuesday by the Mississippi Court of Appeals, vacates the life sentence Edwards received in December 2024 for the May 2022 shooting death of Robert Davis. The decision resets a case that has already seen one mistrial and exposes deep procedural fractures in the Hinds County courtroom overseen by Judge Faye Peterson.

“Based on the totality of the circumstances, we reverse Edwards’ convictions and remand for a new trial,” Judge David McCarty wrote for the majority, joined by Judges Donna Barnes and Deborah McDonald. “This Sixth Amendment is essential to a fair trial. Simple logic requires us to conclude that when something essential to a fair trial did not happen, the trial was not fair.”

The appellate court found that Edwards never knowingly waived his right to an attorney. Instead, the record shows a defendant who repeatedly protested that his appointed attorney failed to communicate with him and failed to access crucial discovery materials, only to be told the docket was too crowded to wait.

Mississippi Appeals Court Overturns Edwards' Murder Conviction, Orders New Trial
Photo: wtva.com

After a 2023 mistrial, Edwards’ first appointed attorneys withdrew. Brandon Dorsey was appointed next, but Edwards told the court Dorsey failed to communicate for weeks and made no filings until February 2024. By fall 2024, they had met only three times; Edwards had been transferred to Tallahatchie County, and Dorsey’s motion to bring him back to Raymond went unaddressed.

Eight days before the retrial, Dorsey moved to withdraw. Judge Peterson granted the motion but denied a continuance, telling Dorsey the 2025 docket would “be full with those TANF cases.” “I would highly suggest you take advantage of being able to try this case now because I don’t know that I’ll have space in 2025 to hear it,” Peterson said. “Do you understand?”

The court then appointed William Mullennix as “hybrid” counsel with less than 72 hours to prepare. The appeals court ruled that the trial court did not follow rules requiring a judge to warn a defendant about the risks of self-representation or secure new counsel before allowing an attorney to withdraw.

“Because Edwards did not waive his right to counsel, the trial court improperly granted Dorsey’s withdrawal,” the majority wrote.

Mississippi Appeals Court Overturns Edwards' Murder Conviction, Orders New Trial
Photo: yahoo.com

Judge Anthony Lawrence concurred in part and dissented in part, joined by Judges Virginia Carlton, John Weddle, and Amy Lassiter St. Pe. Lawrence agreed the trial should have been delayed but disagreed that Edwards’ right to counsel was violated, saying Mullennix provided meaningful representation. Judge Latrice Westbrooks filed a separate concurrence joined by Judges McDonald, McCarty, Jack Wilson, and John Emfinger.

The underlying case stems from the shooting at the Clinton home of Shadow Robinson. Robinson testified she heard gunshots and saw Davis lying facedown in the hallway; she said she did not see Edwards discharge a weapon and that she only saw sparks, but she testified that she saw Edwards with a gun and that he was the one who shot Davis.

Prosecutors used surveillance video from Funtime Skateland and Ring doorbell footage at trial. Edwards was arrested after a chase in New Orleans on May 3, 2022.

Edwards was also convicted of possession of a firearm by a felon, carrying a 10-year sentence that was also reversed.