Montana AG Knudsen Takes Over Review of Billings Senior High Stabbing Case

Montana’s top law-enforcement office has taken over the criminal review of a January stabbing at Billings Senior High School after local prosecutors declined to pursue felony charges, a move that resets a case that has divided teachers, students and families for ten months.

Attorney General Austin Knudsen’s office confirmed Wednesday it is conducting an independent review, pulling the matter back from the Billings City Attorney’s Office, which had been preparing its own assessment of potential misdemeanor counts, NonStop Local Billings reported. Communications Director Amanda Braynack told the outlet the review is underway but offered no timeline for a decision.

The intervention by the state’s highest prosecutorial authority follows a charged October decision by then–Yellowstone County Attorney Scott Twito, who announced after a nine-month investigation that his office would not file felony charges against the student involved.

Twito, who resigned last month to become Montana’s U.S. attorney, handed the file to City Attorney Gina Dahl for a municipal review. That handoff — and the absence of a felony count — prompted demonstrations outside the high school and the county courthouse by educators and students demanding stronger workplace protections.

The night the wrestling meet cleared out

The incident unfolded on January 13, after regular school hours, while a crowded dual wrestling meet was underway in the gym. The stabbing occurred on the third floor of the building, sending both the teacher and the student to the hospital and forcing a full evacuation of the school, according to KTVQ reporting.

Superintendent Erwin Garcia identified the teacher as Jason Rader, who was placed on paid administrative leave immediately after the incident and remains on leave.

bilings senior stabbing.jpg
Photo: ktvq.com

“Throughout this time, I saw teachers and students in tears while our counselors and Crisis Team supported them in the aftermath of this event,” Garcia wrote in a statement to media outlets last month. “The absence of formal felony charges does not ease the pain or provide the clear resolution our community needs.”

A case passed between offices

The procedural path has been unusual. County attorneys typically handle felonies under state law; city attorneys handle municipal ordinance violations and state-law misdemeanors within city limits. Dahl confirmed to KTVQ on October 21 that her office had begun an independent review, saying, “We take our prosecutorial responsibilities seriously and are committed to ensuring that any determination is made thoughtfully, fairly, and in accordance with our legal and ethical obligations.”

Ten days later, on October 30, Dahl said she was asked to pause that review because Knudsen’s office would step in. She told MTN she does not know why the state assumed jurisdiction and has heard nothing further on the review’s status. The Attorney General’s office, in an email to KTVQ, repeated only that it “is currently reviewing the case.”

“The precedent this sets for educators everywhere concerns us a great deal. The ramifications and downstream effects go far beyond this one instance and we intend to make our position on the County Attorney’s decision widely known.”

Lance Edward, president of the Billings Education Association, told KTVQ.

The union has backed Rader, stating it is unaware of any wrongdoing on his part. The student involved has met graduation requirements and is no longer enrolled in the district, Garcia said.

District seeks its own answers

Frustrated by the criminal process, the Billings Public Schools district launched a parallel internal investigation. Garcia said the district would petition a court for access to criminal justice records from the police and county attorney’s investigation. As of Wednesday, the district had not provided an update on that effort or on whether a court has granted the records request.

In the interim, Senior High has reduced the number of accessible entrances during the school day, issued access cards to police officers for rapid entry, upgraded radio communication systems and applied for grants to improve visual notification systems, Garcia wrote.

Knudsen, who was raised in Culbertson, served as Speaker of the Montana House of Representatives from 2015 to 2019 before term limits pushed him toward a successful run for Roosevelt County Attorney. He won the Attorney General’s office in 2020, defeating the state deputy Attorney General in the Republican primary and Raph Graybill in the general election, and was sworn in on January 4, 2021.

Knudsen’s office has not set a public deadline for its review. Dahl’s city office remains on hold. The next movement in the case will come when the Attorney General announces whether the state will pursue charges, decline them, or refer the matter back to the city for misdemeanor consideration.