A Missoula district court judge on Tuesday blocked Montana from enforcing a 2025 law that defines sex as a strict biological binary in state code, granting a preliminary injunction against Senate Bill 437.
The ruling by District Court Judge Leslie Halligan halts a statute Gov. Greg Gianforte signed this spring, nearly a year after the Legislature adjourned, Daily Montanan reported. Plaintiffs — a group of transgender, intersex and Two-Spirit Montanans — argued the law would force them to interact with state agencies, from the Motor Vehicle Division to the marriage license bureau, under classifications that do not match their gender identity or medical circumstances.

The legal history here is unusual. Sen. Carl Glimm, R-Kila, sponsored a nearly identical bill in the 2023 session. A district court struck that measure down in June 2024 for violating the state Constitution’s single-subject rule.
In a separate order on that same bill in February 2025, Halligan found that defining sex as a binary “explicitly excludes (two plaintiffs) from the definition of human beings.” The state argued that ruling was moot after the single-subject decision, but Halligan said it remained relevant given the 2025 legislation.
Glimm reintroduced the definitions this year under Senate Bill 437 with a clarified title, though he acknowledged the substance was unchanged. “The mechanics of this bill will remain the same,” he told Daily Montanan.
Danahy characterized that delay as a tactic to evade judicial scrutiny.
Halligan, a University of Montana law graduate, was appointed to the 4th Judicial District Court by Gov. Steve Bullock in May 2015 to fill a vacancy. She won an unopposed retention election in November 2016 with 83.51 percent of the vote.
The state defended the law by citing specific interests: athletic teams and sex-segregated sports, correctional classifications, family and parental law, and health record keeping.