Muskingum Lets Go Matt Nardo After 0-10 Season

Muskingum let go Matt Nardo after the Fighting Muskies absorbed a 78-21 loss at Baldwin Wallace to finish 0-10, FootballScoop reported.

The defeat closed a second season that saw Muskingum outscored 488-192 across ten games. Nardo leaves New Concord with a 4-16 record after a February 2025 hire that brought him back to the program where he earned his master’s degree in 2007 and served as a graduate assistant from 2005 through 2008.

His predecessor, Erik Ieuter, went 27-36 over seven seasons but posted three five-win campaigns in his last four years, including a 5-5 mark in 2024. Muskingum has not finished above .500 in any season dating back to 1998, according to D3football.com records.

“Two years is a short runway for any head coach, but especially at the Division III level,” a source close to the program told FootballScoop.

Muskingum Lets Go Matt Nardo After 0-10 Season

The first year offered a foundation. The Muskies took then-No. 22 Baldwin Wallace to the wire on Senior Day before falling 35-28 and finished 4-6 overall, 4-4 in conference, good for fifth place.

Year two went the other way.

The roster lost record-setting quarterback Garrett Gurney and a large senior group after 2025, leaving the 2026 squad unable to close the gap in a league that includes Mount Union and an unbeaten, surging Baldwin Wallace squad.

Before Muskingum, Nardo spent three seasons as head coach at Bluffton (2022-2024), going 9-21. His résumé runs through high school, Division II, and Division III stops across Kansas, Florida, and Ohio.

Nardo’s staff made a point to reach high school coaches.

Muskingum had not announced the move as of Wednesday afternoon.