The recount shifted the margin by a single vote in Merrick’s favor.
The race drew partisan scrutiny. Some Democrats criticized Scalise for requesting a recount while simultaneously urging Democrat Kimberly Hardy to pursue one in her congressional race against Republican incumbent David Rouzer. Hardy’s margin was wider, spanning eight counties and over 300,000 ballots. She conceded the Sunday before the deadline, saying she would run again in 2028.
Recount Data Shows Minimal Margin Changes
A Fair Vote analysis of statewide recounts from 2000 to 2025 found an average margin shift of 0.03% of the total vote, which would amount to about 13 votes in this district. The actual recount in House District 20 changed the margin by one vote, removing five ballots total — two from Merrick and three from Scalise.
Fair Vote and other advocates support a 0.1% automatic recount trigger, which would have been roughly 44 votes here. Scalise would still have needed to request a recount under that standard.
Scalise could have pursued a sample hand-to-eye recount, a step that led to a full hand recount in the 2022 New Hanover County school board primary. Nelson Beaulieu overcame a three-vote deficit through three recount stages to win that Democratic primary by two votes, though he lost the general election.
Protest history and tone
In 2024, Scalise filed a protest over the election office’s failure to count roughly 2,000 absentee ballots on Election Day. The Board of Elections, then with a Democratic majority, dismissed the protest 3-2 on party lines despite acknowledging the office had violated the law.
Scalise said before this year’s canvass that he would accept the results "with grace." WHQR’s Ben Schachtman wrote that Scalise did so, calling it "an encouraging development: candidates who run a good race, play the cards they’re dealt, and know when to fold."
Cash-for-votes referral to FBI
Separately, the North Carolina State Board of Elections has referred a 2023 "cash for votes" allegation to the FBI. Then-NC GOP Chair Jason Simmons claimed a voter was offered money to support three Democratic Wilmington City Council candidates. The local GOP chair, John Hinnant, did not dispute reporting that he distrusted the complainant.
The State Board confirmed this month that its investigative team handed the case to the FBI earlier this year. The FBI has not responded to inquiries from the North State Journal, which first reported the referral.