Netflix Transforms Toronto’s Sherway Gardens Into ‘Win the Mall’ Production Set

Netflix transformed a vacant wing of Toronto’s Sherway Gardens into a 400,000-square-foot production set for its upcoming reality competition series, “Win the Mall,” after the 355-year-old Hudson’s Bay Company’s collapse created a massive vacancy in the shopping center.

Why did producers choose Toronto for a massive mall set?

Charles Wachter searched across North America for an ideal location before selecting the shopping centre he frequented during his childhood in Toronto.

“But at the same time, we couldn't shoot in a mall all day because it's full of people. We couldn't shoot in a mall just at night because it's a game about real people and real people get tired, just like producers get tired,” Charles Wachter, showrunner for Netflix, said.

The closure of the Hudson’s Bay Company provided the precise footprint needed for production. The defunct department store left a three-storey vacancy that allowed the crew to build a comprehensive base of operations without disrupting everyday shoppers.

How does the game show work inside the set?

“Win the Mall” features 10 teams of two who live inside the shopping centre and compete in challenges to gain ownership of individual stores. Each commercial space offers specific advantages, ranging from a luxury bedding boutique that doubles as sleeping quarters to a fried chicken franchise providing snacks during production.

Netflix Transforms Toronto's Sherway Gardens Into 'Win the Mall' Production Set
Photo: toronto.citynews.ca

Contenders vie for prizes such as a year’s worth of cosmetics or $40,000 in jewelry. The team that successfully accumulates ownership of all participating stores by the end of the season secures a million-dollar grand prize.

“It’s this sort of hyper-surreal experience,” Wachter said on a recent video call. “It’s a fantasy mall,” he said, adding that the high-concept project gamifies consumerism.

What challenges came with filming across 200 retailers?

Producers negotiated contracts with roughly 200 different retailers operating within the Cadillac Fairview-owned shopping centre. Brand integrations played a central role in the production schedule, requiring a dedicated department to manage logos, storefront displays, and financial agreements.

The crew established a war room featuring a laminated floor plan to track shifting brand permissions in real time. Certain brand partners without Canadian storefronts even had temporary facades constructed, while other businesses kept their lights on after closing hours to appear in background shots.

Production within the multi-level cover set typically commenced around 4 p.m. and continued until the commercial spaces locked their doors for the night. Crew members and cameras then moved into the active common areas to shoot physical challenges after hours.

Are shopping malls experiencing a commercial rebound?

Wachter maintains that shopping centers are witnessing a resurgence driven by younger consumers rediscovering physical retail spaces. He attributes the closure of department stores like Hudson’s Bay to a shift away from traditional private equity business models rather than a decline in the appeal of malls.

How Netflix turned a Toronto mall into the set of its latest game show
Photo: thespec.com

“I think Gen Alpha and Gen Z have rediscovered how much fun it is to go to a place that’s full of life and full of people and products,” Wachter said.

Sherway Gardens opened in 1971 as the Rouse Company’s first Canadian mall on the former Sheridan Nurseries farm that gave the site its portmanteau name. The 100-acre property cost roughly CA$21.5 million to develop and debuted with an S-shaped layout, 127 stores and a 31-foot central skylight.

Its original Gourmet Fair food court, inspired by James Rouse’s “community picnic” vision, is credited as the company’s first successful enclosed-mall food court and preceded the better-known Paramus Park model by three years. A 1975 expansion reshaped the centre into a figure-eight configuration and added 75 retail spaces.

Disclaimer: The cultural analyses and financial data presented in this article are based on available public records and industry metrics at the time of publication.