New DOL Contractor Rule No Relief for Connecticut Employers Under Stricter ABC Test

The U.S. Department of Labor released its final independent contractor rule on November 19, reverting to a Trump-era framework that emphasizes control and profit opportunity. For Connecticut businesses, however, the federal shift changes nothing because the state enforces a stricter “ABC test” that presumes employment unless a company proves all three prongs.

The federal rule, set to take effect 60 days after publication in the Federal Register, replaces the 2024 Biden-era economic reality test with a version close to the 2021 Trump administration approach.

It centers on two core factors: the degree of control a company exercises over the work and the worker’s genuine opportunity for profit or loss through business investment or initiative. When those factors align, the Department of Labor says the classification is usually settled. Three additional factors — skill, permanence, and integration into the business — serve as tiebreakers.

Why Connecticut employers face a different standard

Connecticut does not use the federal economic reality test for its own wage, hour, or unemployment purposes.

The state Department of Labor applies the “ABC test,” a conjunctive standard requiring a business to prove three distinct conditions: the worker is free from direction and control; the service is performed outside the usual course of the company’s business or its places of business; and the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade of the same nature.

Dan Schwartz, a partner at Shipman & Goodwin, wrote in his Connecticut Employment Law Blog post republished by CBIA that the test itself didn’t change and that Connecticut has more than one test.

“It starts with a presumption of employment. The statute treats the service as employment ‘unless and until’ the company shows otherwise. The burden is on employers.”

— Dan Schwartz, Partner, Shipman & Goodwin

Unlike the federal balancing approach, missing any single prong of the ABC test makes the worker an employee under Connecticut law. The state also measures control by the contractual right to direct the work, not merely the day-to-day exercise of that right.

A newly formed LLC created in response to a contractor offer does not satisfy Part C, according to the Connecticut Department of Labor, though working for only one client is not automatically disqualifying.

Court ruling narrows business definition

The Connecticut Supreme Court has provided limited breathing room. In Standard Oil, the court held that customers’ homes were not the company’s “places of business” under Part B, allowing certain installers to remain independent contractors. But that ruling applied the existing ABC test; it did not relax the standard itself.

Complicating matters further, the Department of Revenue Services follows common-law rules for tax purposes, while the Workers’ Compensation Commission applies its own factor-based analysis. The same worker can be classified differently depending on which state agency is asking.

What Connecticut businesses should do now

Schwartz advises running every Connecticut contractor through the ABC test first. If the relationship survives that analysis, it will likely pass federal muster; the reverse is not true. He recommends stripping contracts of reserved control rights the company does not actually need and ensuring those rights are not exercised in practice.

Part C scrutiny should focus on whether the contractor maintains other clients, a business presence, insurance, and a genuine independent trade — or whether the business entity appeared the week the offer was made.

Connecticut, the third-smallest state by area with more than 3.6 million residents as of 2024, adopted the Fundamental Orders in 1639, considered by some the first written constitution in Western history. That framework influenced the federal structure Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth advanced at the 1787 Constitutional Convention, where their compromise created Congress’s bicameral design still used today.

Schwartz wrote that none of this means a company can’t use independent contractors in Connecticut; it can, but the relationship has to be legitimate under Connecticut’s test, not just Washington’s.