New Mexico education advocates and lawmakers gathered Tuesday to denounce the state’s entry into a federal tax-credit program they call a voucher scheme in disguise, setting up a clash with Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham over the future of public school funding.
The Federal Scholarship Tax Credit, created by President Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act last year, lets eligible taxpayers claim up to $1,700 annually for donations to nonprofit “scholarship granting organizations” that then award K-12 scholarships for public and private school expenses.
States can opt in to the program, which takes effect on Jan. 1, 2027. Earlier this month, Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham announced that New Mexico would become the 32nd state to participate.
“This is a voucher scheme,” said Bethany Jarrell, president of the National Education Association New Mexico, at the news conference. “While the New Mexico Constitution establishes a responsibility to provide education for all children, the scholarship organizations are private and do not have the constitutional responsibility to educate every child.”
That constitutional guarantee sits at the center of the landmark Yazzie/Martinez ruling, which found the state failed to provide equitable support for at-risk students — English learners, Native American students, low-income families and students with disabilities.
“New Mexico must not import a policy that risks deepening educational inequities while leaving public schools with greater responsibility and fewer resources,” said Loretta Trujillo, executive director of Transform Education NM and a Yazzie/Martinez reform advocate.
Lujan Grisham’s communications director, Michael Coleman, told Source NM in an emailed statement that the governor “would have preferred more direct federal investment in public education in lieu of this tax credit — full stop.”
But faced with a binary choice — opt in and keep donation flows in state, or opt out and watch that money go elsewhere — she chose to participate. “Given those limited choices, Governor Lujan Grisham decided to keep that money in New Mexico where it belongs,” Coleman said.
The program takes effect Jan. 1, 2027. Coleman added the credit is open to public school students and the administration is “doing everything she can to make sure they benefit from it.”
Democratic lawmakers who have long opposed vouchers called the decision a betrayal of the Legislature’s equity work. Sen. Linda Lopez (D-Albuquerque) said she was “very disappointed,” calling the program “a backdoor entry to remove money from our public schools.” She vowed that “as we move forward under a new governor, I will stand with my colleagues to say no, we will not.”

Rep. Andrés Romero (D-Albuquerque), chair of the House Education Committee, told Source NM the move undermines legislative efforts for Yazzie/Martinez students. “These voucher programs in the states that have had them disproportionately gone to affluent families and students, and have benefited private school over public schools,” Romero said, dismissing claims the program will fund after-school programs as “a hope and a wish.”
The opt-in is done, but the fight over implementation — and whether lawmakers can block or reshape the program before 2027 — is just beginning.