New Orleans Judge Orders Evidence Preservation After Tanker Strikes Paddleboat on Mississippi River

Tanker crew must save evidence following New Orleans crash on Saturday.

The Atlantic Asphalt tanker struck the American Heritage paddleboat at Thalia Street Wharf on the lower Mississippi River, an incident that has quickly spun into a complex web of civil litigation and federal investigation.

This isn’t just about river traffic; it’s about how maritime law balances the duty to preserve evidence against the powerful financial maneuvers of corporate defense against multiple civil lawsuits, as the Advocate reported.

A New Orleans judge issued a directive applying to the tanker's steering, tracking, and data systems, a ruling beyond the initial arrest warrant Chief U.S. District Judge Wendy Vitter issued following a lawsuit from the Port of New Orleans, the Guardian reported.

NTSB Officials Hold Press Conference On Collision Of Tanker And Cruise Ship In New Orleans — Forbes Breaking News

Judge Kern Reese orders evidence preservation

Judge Kern Reese of New Orleans’ Civil District Court signed the order requiring the crew, operators, insurers, and affiliates of the Atlantic Asphalt to preserve all evidence related to the vessel’s operation, maintenance, and collision involvement.

Federal investigators have been working to determine what happened when the 15,000-ton vessel executed a hard starboard turn into the docked cruise ship.

Lawyers seek limit on payout

Meanwhile, attorneys for the tanker’s owners filed in federal court seeking to cap potential damages, aiming to invoke the 1851 Limitation of Liability Act.

They argued that damages weren’t caused by any fault or negligence on the part of their clients, Nave Shipping, the Liberia-based owner, and Thome Ship Management, the Singapore-based management company, the Advocate reported.

If they succeed, the court could limit payouts to the vessel and cargo value, which their attorneys pegged at $24.5 million.

“The crew were not aware of any steering issues with the vessel at the time of the casualty and had no knowledge suggesting that such a failure was likely to occur.”

This defense directly challenges the general presumption in maritime law that moving ships hitting parked vessels are at fault, the nola.com reported.

NO.cruisewrap.111526.02.JPG
Photo: theadvocate.com

NTSB review impacts plaintiffs

“The NTSB, as good as they are at what they do, won’t look at all of the things that we will need to look it.” Walt Leger Jr

This preservation order ensures plaintiffs’ attorneys can inspect the ship once the NTSB completes its safety review.

Port seeks damage compensation

The Port of New Orleans filed a lawsuit seeking over $1 million in damages from the tanker’s owner and operator, covering terminal repairs and cleanup operations, the Guardian reported.

Press conference after tanker collides with river cruiser near Port of New Orleans — FOX10 News

The Port also requested permission for the tanker to be seized and sold to cover damage costs, a request approved by Judge Vitter on Friday.

The tanker’s attorneys said that the owners expect additional lawsuits from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and American Cruise Lines, the Advocate reported.