Seventy years after a Columbus civil rights leader was gunned down in his office, a fresh release of federal records is rewriting the official story of a murder that went unpunished and a killer who died under suspicious circumstances a year later.
The documents, made public Nov. 13 by the Civil Rights Cold Case Records Review Board, detail the 1956 assassination of Dr. Thomas H. Brewer, a 61-year-old physician and the city’s most prominent Black activist, and the shadowy death of his shooter, Luico Flowers, a white department store owner. The Ledger-Enquirer reported the timeline this week, drawing on the newly unsealed FBI and police files.
Months before the shooting, the FBI opened an investigation into Brewer for alleged communist ties, interviewing him on Jan. 18, 1956. He denied any affiliation with the Civil Rights Congress, a group linked to the Communist Party. The bureau closed the probe as “unproductive” by April, but the surveillance file survived.
Tensions between the two men escalated in February 1956 over a police incident outside Flowers’ store. On Feb. 18, Flowers shot Brewer seven times in Brewer’s office. Flowers was charged with murder two days later, but a Muscogee County grand jury refused to indict him on Feb. 29.
An hour later, police found him dying of a gunshot wound to the head outside the entrance. He died hours later.
A typed letter arrived at the Columbus Police Department eight days later, postmarked New York.
Addressed to the chief and Flowers’ family, it read in part: “It is fruitless for you to continue to search for the slayer of BASTARD Flowers… The Labor Union saw to it that he got his just reward. Can’t you see how quietly it was done? He killed a quiet man. Quietly the Grand Jury refused to indict him. Quietly it was all forgotten, and quietly will Flowers be forgotten.”
Despite the note’s explicit claim of retaliation, a coroner’s jury ruled on April 5, 1957, that Flowers died by his own hand, concluding “there was no other individual involved in his death.” The Georgia Bureau of Investigation had opened a probe weeks earlier, but the suicide finding closed the book locally.
The federal government took a longer look decades later. The FBI reopened an inquiry into civil rights-era cold cases in April 2006. By Nov. 25 of that year, Columbus Police Chief Ricky Boren told agents the department could not locate internal records on either death — they may have been lost in a 1960 water leak at headquarters.
The FBI formally closed its review of Brewer’s death on April 6, 2007, ruling “this matter does not constitute a prosecutable violation of the federal criminal civil rights statutes.”
Congress created the Civil Rights Cold Case Records Review Board in 2019 to declassify investigative files on unsolved civil rights violations from 1940 to 1979. The board was not staffed until February 2022, after President Joe Biden’s nominees were confirmed by the Senate, and its original four-year mandate was later extended through 2027.
The Review Board’s release does not solve the mystery. It does, however, place the original FBI surveillance of Brewer, the grand jury’s refusal to indict, the anonymous confession letter, and the convenient suicide ruling side by side in the public record for the first time.