NJ Activist Acquitted of Obstruction After ICE Standoff

Activist Asma Elhuni won an acquittal on Tuesday, Nov. 18, in Trenton municipal court against charges of obstruction and disorderly conduct stemming from her August 2025 arrest during a standoff with immigration agents.

The municipal court trial, which began on Nov. 3, centered on an incident on Bayard Street where Elhuni and fellow rapid responders from Resistencia en Acción NJ shouted to a family inside that they did not have to open their door to federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents lacking a warrant, nj.com reported.

City police officers responded to the scene and eventually arrested Elhuni while she stood on a nearby sidewalk. According to social media footage of the confrontation, a police sergeant named Sgt. Sheehan Miles established a “zone” that the activists were accused of violating, yahoo.com noted.

Judge Marc A. McKithen ruled in Elhuni’s favor, finding her not guilty on all counts. Speaking after the verdict, Elhuni praised the judge's courage and emphasized the wider impact for community advocacy.

NJ Activist Acquitted of Obstruction After ICE Standoff
Photo: yahoo.com

“This is a win for the community, a win for free speech and a win for rapid responders,” Elhuni said, according to nj.com. “And it’s a win for the right to tell people their rights, that we absolutely have a right to warn people [when ICE is at their door.]”

Elhuni’s defense attorney, Gerardo Mejia, argued successfully that his client lacked any illegal purpose or intent. He said that the trial featured testimony from Miles and arresting officer Michael Manning, during which one officer admitted under questioning that Elhuni was targeted because “she looked like she was the leader.”

“Peaceful protesting and expressing disagreement with government immigration policies are protected by the First Amendment and are not crimes,” Mejia said, as reported by yahoo.com. “That is a major win, especially since the judge accepted our core argument regarding Ms. Elhuni’s lack of illegal purpose or intent.”

Despite the courtroom victory, Elhuni maintains that the fight is far from over. She and her organization argue that Trenton police officers routinely fail to follow New Jersey’s Immigrant Trust Directive, a state-codified policy that limits local law enforcement cooperation with federal immigration authorities.

“We really feel that the Trenton PD actually supports ICE and uses excuses to support ICE,” Elhuni told nj.com. “That means they don’t see a problem with what ICE is doing to their community members – if they really feel they are community members.”

Trenton police spokesman Capt. David Ordille strongly disputed those claims. He maintained that the department’s personnel strictly adhere to the state’s directive.

Elhuni’s legal calendar remains crowded. She faces a pending case stemming from another arrest this past August, when Trenton police pulled her over after she followed ICE agents through the city. Police alleged she violated multiple traffic laws, with one officer remarking that she could not drive and was honking her horn erratically.

Elhuni was also scheduled to appear in court on Nov. 19 regarding her arrest earlier this spring outside Delaney Hall in Newark, where police detained dozens of demonstrators at the immigration jail.

Reflecting on the ongoing cycle of arrests among local advocates, Elhuni pointed to a disconnect between official rhetoric and on-the-ground reality in New Jersey.

“This is really showing one thing, that in a so-called progressive state, ‘Have we have really come far enough?'” Elhuni said, according to yahoo.com. “We have a lot of verbiage [from officials] that is not followed by any action.”