Three nonbinary runners sued the City of Philadelphia and marathon director Kathleen Titus on Tuesday, alleging the Philadelphia Marathon violates the city’s Fair Practices Ordinance by barring nonbinary athletes from its professional division.
The complaint, filed in Common Pleas Court days before the 40,000-runner weekend, argues that restricting professional registration to “male” or “female” categories denies nonbinary competitors equal access to $10,000 first-place prizes, free entry, travel stipends, and dedicated race-day support.
Winter Parts, Reed Williams, and Miche Palmer — all veterans of the event — say the city has ignored years of advocacy and a 2025 Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations “right to sue” notice, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported.
“The Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance has a very specific protection prohibiting discrimination on the basis of gender identity,” said Maia Goodell, the attorney representing the runners.

A two-tier system
The marathon added a nonbinary option for open-division runners in 2022 and equalized open-division prize money at $4,000 in 2024. But the professional division — where winners earn $10,000 plus complimentary registration, starting-line priority, and potential travel and lodging — remains binary. Williams won the nonbinary open division in 2024 and collected $4,000; the professional men’s and women’s winners each took home $10,000.
“We’re not in this for the money,” Parts said. “We’re in it for the equality.”
Years of negotiation, then a lawsuit
Queer Run and Lez Run, two of the city’s largest LGBTQ+ run clubs, began requesting a nonbinary professional category in 2022. They met with Titus before the 2023 race to discuss qualifying standards and logistics, said Josh Fernandez, president and executive director of Queer Run.
“We brought up examples from other races. We tried to address any practical questions that were being raised,” Fernandez said. The marathon declined, citing guidance from USA Track & Field.
After the clubs filed a PCHR complaint in July 2025 and gathered more than 900 petition signatures, the commission issued the right-to-sue notice that cleared the way for this week’s filing, The Philadelphia Inquirer reported.
Misgendering at the finish line
The suit describes structural failures beyond prize money. After Parts finished as the first nonbinary runner in the marathon’s open division in 2022, finish-line staff directed runners toward male or female chutes with no nonbinary option.
“The runner was forced to choose how to be misgendered,” the complaint says. Parts, who presents femininely, chose the men’s chute to avoid accusations of sandbagging. Official results later listed all nonbinary entrants as either male or female. Williams witnessed similar misgendering in 2023.
Broader political context
The litigation lands amid separate lawsuits alleging a pattern of LGBTQ+ discrimination inside the Parker administration. Former Office of LGBTQ+ Affairs director Celena Morrison and former Chief DEI Officer Brandee Anderson both sued the city this year.
Morrison’s filing alleges that Chief of Staff Tiffany Thurman told her Mayor Cherelle Parker viewed Morrison’s advocacy for nonbinary marathoners as a “hindrance to the administration,” The Philadelphia Inquirer reported. The mayor’s office has not responded to those allegations.
The city law department and Titus declined to comment on pending litigation. A hearing date has not been set. Parts and Williams are not racing this weekend; Palmer plans to run with training partners. “It’s a complicated set of emotions,” Parts said ahead of the weekend. “It sucks that this race is not fully including us.”