NYC Council Introduces Bill Banning Boiling Live Lobsters

New York City Council members introduced a bill Thursday that would ban boiling live lobsters and other crustaceans, proposing a $100 fine per animal after an initial warning.

The measure, sponsored by Councilmen Oswald Feliz of the Bronx and Harvey Epstein of Manhattan, would require restaurants to kill the creatures before cooking them — typically by stunning them electrically or freezing them, then severing the nervous system with a knife.

Establishments could still serve lobster and crab, but the traditional live-boil method would become illegal, mirroring laws already in place in Switzerland, New Zealand, England, Austria, Norway and parts of Australia, New York Post reported. The boil ban would apply to any living crustaceans, including “but not limited to lobsters and crabs,” according to the new bill proposed on Thursday.

Feliz framed the legislation as a basic cruelty prevention. “Boiling an animal alive is the textbook definition of animal cruelty,” he told the Post. “Some argue that lobsters don’t feel pain. If they don’t feel pain, why do they thrash around and desperately try to escape when thrown into boiling water?”

“Boiling any animal alive is animal cruelty,” he said. “I also want to be clear: this bill does not remove lobster from the menu or prevent anyone from eating it,” he added. “Everyone is completely free to enjoy as much lobster as they want.”

NYC Council Introduces Bill Banning Boiling Live Lobsters
Photo: dnyuz.com

The bill lands in an industry already contending with soaring rents, food costs and labor expenses.

“Restaurants are fighting high rents, food costs, labor costs and taxes. “The lobsters might be safe, but the restaurant business is getting cooked!” “This is nuts,” said retired New York Italian restaurant icon Angelo Vivolo. “What’s next, do they want to introduce not using cow for meat or forget about prosciutto at an Italian restaurant? Fuggadaboutit! “It’s idiocy,” he railed. This regulation is absolutely insane.”

Animal welfare advocates cite studies suggesting crustaceans exhibit pain responses similar to mammals. Other experts disagree, arguing the animals’ nervous systems are more comparable to insects and lack the complexity for suffering. The scientific split leaves lawmakers legislating on unsettled ground.

Feliz, a Bronx native who won a 2021 special election to succeed Ritchie Torres, previously worked as a tenant lawyer defending residents against eviction and taught as an adjunct professor at Hostos Community College. He chaired the Small Business Committee during his first Council term and, after his 2025 re-election, was appointed to lead the Public Safety Committee under Speaker Julie Menin.

The proposal follows a 2019 City Council ban on foie gras that has remained tied up in court appeals for years. A separate bill introduced Thursday would also prohibit giving away live goldfish as prizes. Neither measure is expected to reach a vote soon, but the lobster bill has already drawn a sharp line between animal welfare priorities and the economic realities of the city’s restaurant sector.

“This is nuts. What’s next, do they want to introduce not using cow for meat or forget about prosciutto at an Italian restaurant? Fuggadaboutit! It’s idiocy.”

Angelo Vivolo, retired New York Italian restaurant icon, told New York Post

“I love New York. But when politicians start worrying more about lobsters than the people trying to make a living, something is seriously wrong.”

Zach Erdem, chef and restaurateur, told New York Post