O’Keefe, Higby Appear in Court on Identity Theft, Voting Charges

Monday was supposed to be a routine arraignment.

Conservative activists James O’Keefe and Cam Higby appeared in Hennepin County District Court on charges of identity theft and unlawful voting, accused of misrepresenting themselves to election judges during Minnesota’s August primary. Outside the Hennepin County Public Safety Facility, dueling protesters clashed with bullhorns and insults. Inside Courtroom 143 — usually a sparse holding pen for daily bail reviews — media, supporters, and security packed the benches, Star Tribune reported.

The hearing lasted minutes. Judge Luis Bartolomei released both men on their own recognizance with no bail required, setting the next appearance for January 13. Prosecutors had asked the court to bar O’Keefe and Higby from speaking to each other while the case proceeds.

Their attorneys called that an infringement on the defense. Bartolomei sided with the defense, ordering only that the pair have no contact with the election judges and alleged victims named in the charging documents.

Swarmed: Local Minnesota news covered our court appearance with Cam Higby today. — O’Keefe Media Group

“There’s just absolutely no reason for that other than to try to interfere with the defense,”

Christopher Madel, O’Keefe’s attorney

Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty’s office filed the felony charges in October, alleging O’Keefe and Higby visited multiple precincts on August 11, gave poll workers the names of registered voters — some deceased — and filmed the interactions with hidden cameras.

Neither man was issued a ballot. The pair later posted the footage online, framing it as an exposé of Minnesota’s vouching system, which allows a registered voter to vouch for up to eight unregistered residents in the same precinct.

State officials say less than 0.6% of votes cast in the 2024 general election used that process. Moriarty called elections “the bedrock of democracy” and said unlawful conduct related to them would be held accountable, according to a news release cited by Courthouse News.

O'Keefe, Higby Appear in Court on Identity Theft, Voting Charges
Photo: kdhnews.com

O’Keefe and Higby maintain the operation was a First Amendment-protected investigation. In a recorded statement, O’Keefe said his media group trained participants never to sign an affidavit or touch a ballot. “This is not political, it is fundamental,” he said.

“It is about whether citizens still have the right to question their government. This is now a landmark First Amendment case, and every American’s right to speak truth to power has been put on the line.”

The courtroom itself wasn’t immune to the tension. At one point, a court staff member shouted down someone who had started a voice memo on an iPhone. Bartolomei warned the gallery that recording proceedings — including via smart glasses — would bring contempt sanctions.

Outside, the noise never stopped. As the defendants slipped out a side door to a waiting car, a man with a bullhorn screamed about the Epstein files. An O’Keefe supporter asked him why he was so “stupid.” Counterprotesters had earlier labeled O’Keefe and his allies “white supremacists,” Courthouse News reported.

Higby’s attorney, Ryan Garry, noted his client spent more than 30 hours traveling — driving and taking two flights — to make the hearing after weekend air-travel chaos. The judge accepted that as further reason to skip bail.