The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has ruled that a town cannot block a large solar project simply because it requires cutting down trees in a heavily forested community, sending the case back for a site-specific review.
In a decision that clarifies the reach of the state’s Dover Amendment, the court found that Petersham’s Zoning Board of Appeals violated the law when it denied a special permit for Sunpin Energy Services’ ground-mounted array based on general concerns about deforestation.
Because Petersham is ninety-seven percent forested, the justices wrote, a categorical refusal based on tree removal amounts to a blanket ban on large-scale solar, which the statute forbids.
The ruling vacates a Land Court decision that had upheld the denial and orders the ZBA to conduct a specific analysis of whether this particular project’s tree cutting threatens public health, safety, or welfare.
The Statutory Collision
The dispute centers on G.L. c. 40A, § 3, paragraph 9 — the solar provision of the Dover Amendment — which mandates that municipalities provide a “reasonable opportunity” for solar development and may not “unduly interfere” with siting.
The ZBA denied Sunpin’s application after one of its three members voted no, citing the project’s anticipated tree cutting as contrary to the town bylaw’s purpose of protecting general welfare. Because the board required a unanimous vote under G.L. c. 40A, § 9, that single dissent killed the permit.
Sunpin sued in Land Court in 2021, arguing the denial was arbitrary and violated the Dover Amendment. The trial court sided with the ZBA, finding the member had correctly applied the bylaw’s criteria. The Appeals Court reversed, ruling the board had improperly preferred forest preservation over solar energy and relied on conjecture about future development.
A Narrower Path for Local Control
The SJC agreed the denial could not stand, but on different grounds than the Appeals Court. The justices held that while towns retain zoning authority, they must ground any denial in a site-specific determination that blocking the project is necessary to protect public health, safety, or welfare. Generalized concerns about tree loss in a town that is almost entirely woods do not meet that standard.
“The ZBA had misapplied the public health, safety, or welfare standard by relying on general concerns about tree cutting,” the court wrote in its opinion. “Given that the Town is ninety-seven percent forest, the ZBA’s denial of the special permit application due to significant tree cutting would amount to a blanket ban on large-scale ground-mounted solar energy systems in the Town.”
The decision leaves the door open — barely — for the ZBA to deny the permit on remand, but only if it produces a record showing this specific parcel’s deforestation creates a concrete threat. That is a significantly higher bar than the general bylaw consistency argument the board originally used.
Petersham, in Worcester County, is the largest town by land area in the county and the fifth-largest in Massachusetts, a result of absorbing the former towns of Dana, Greenwich, and part of Prescott when the Quabbin Reservoir was built in 1938.
The population was 1,194 in 2020. The town was the site of the second battle of Shays’ Rebellion on February 4, 1787, and its common anchors a historic district with about 45 buildings on the National Register, including an 1842 Country Store still in operation.
The case returns to the Land Court with instructions to remand to the ZBA for that site-specific analysis. For developers, the ruling reinforces that the Dover Amendment is not a suggestion; for rural municipalities, it shows that preserving community character through tree canopy arguments will require far more rigorous, parcel-level evidence than a general master plan provides.