Utah Lawmakers Propose Shifting Data Center Control to Local Governments, Cutting Tax Incentives

Utah lawmakers unveiled a sweeping plan Wednesday to rewrite the rules governing data centers, putting local governments in charge of approvals and stripping away the tax breaks that have fueled rapid expansion.

The proposal, presented by Rep. Paul Cutler, a Centerville Republican, to the Economic Development and Workforce Services Interim Committee, marks a sharp pivot for a state that has aggressively courted the industry.

It arrives after a summer of ferocious public backlash against the Stratos project — a $100 billion, 40,000-acre development backed by celebrity investor Kevin O’Leary — that contributed to the primary defeat of Senate President Stuart Adams and helped Democrats double their House seats, shattering the GOP supermajority.

Utah Lawmakers Unveil Proposed Data Center Regulations

Local control replaces state authority

Under the planned legislation, only counties, cities, or towns could originate a data center proposal. The Military Installation Development Authority (MIDA), which gave Stratos its initial green light without requiring Box Elder County’s support, would be barred from proposing projects and stripped of any power to override local zoning decisions.

The Utah Inland Port Authority would face the same restriction, though both could still offer technical expertise. During Wednesday’s committee hearing, Rep.

“They get to decide whether a data center is appropriate for their community,” Cutler told the committee. The bill would also require local governments to have policies covering zoning, setbacks, noise, heat, vibration, and architecture before any approval, and it would ban elected officials from signing nondisclosure agreements related to data center deals.

A pair of lark sparrows sit on a fence near a watering trough near Hansel Valley
Photo: deseret.com

Tax incentives on the chopping block

Lawmakers want to redirect the revenue stream. A 250-megawatt facility can generate more than $25 million annually in property taxes — potentially nearing $70 million depending on equipment valuations — and Cutler said the goal is to keep that money local.

His plan would reduce or eliminate the tax incentives currently offered to developers, routing a portion of the new revenue to a state fund for environmental mitigation, Great Salt Lake preservation, and possible statewide property or income tax relief.

“Data centers will happen,” Cutler told reporters after the meeting. “But we can make sure that, in Utah, only the best projects that respect our natural resources, that benefit our local communities, happen.”

Utah lawmakers start drafting data center bills

Framework mandates closed-loop cooling and water replenishment

The framework would require closed-loop cooling systems and mandate that operators replenish the water they consume. Developers would have to provide verified data on water use, energy demand, air emissions, and neighborhood impacts before any vote, with annual reporting and state audits to follow.

The Stratos project, approved for up to 9 gigawatts of power, became the flashpoint for these demands after residents said they were blindsided by its scale and speed. “We’re all concerned about water,” Cutler said. “The intent is that data centers will be required to provide benefits — not only to report on what water they use, but to structure their operations to replenish what they consume.”

Industry pushback grows as retroactive power remains unclear

Cutler acknowledged the shift in influence: public outrage has "given us a lot more leverage over some of the industry partners." He said he has already told hyperscale operators that many tax incentives are disappearing, though he believes the effect will be minimal on project viability.

Whether the legislation could retroactively unwind Stratos — already approved by MIDA — remains unclear; Cutler paused when asked directly and did not commit. Whether the legislation will have the power to “undo” proposed projects is still unclear. “Our intent is to increase local communities’ ability to make their own decisions about whether a data center is appropriate in their community,” Cutler added.

Eye on the Hill: data centers — KSL News Utah

Sen. Chris Wilson, the incoming Senate majority leader and the bill’s floor sponsor, called the drafting a “Herculean effort” with significant work remaining. No bill has been filed, and there is no draft to share. Cutler and Wilson are still gathering feedback from local governments, the governor’s office, and industry stakeholders.

Created by the Utah Legislature in 2007, the Military Installation Development Authority (MIDA) was designed to coordinate development around Hill Air Force Base after Congress authorized the Enhanced Use Lease program in 2002, allowing private developers to build on underutilized military land.

The authority was formed to streamline land use, taxation, and services across the Weber and Davis county jurisdictions encompassing the Falcon Hill Aerospace Research Park, and it now oversees eight active project areas statewide.

The committee’s presentation materials are posted online.