Pennsylvania consumer advocate Darryl Lawrence filed a legal complaint in October with the Public Utility Commission to prevent existing electricity customers from subsidizing the massive energy demands of incoming data centers.
The state’s data center boom has triggered widespread public backlash and driven up electricity bills following record price spikes at power auctions. While major tech companies and utilities publicly agree that data centers should pay for their own grid upgrades and bear reliability risks, the consumer advocate argues that current utility rules lack legally binding teeth.
“We just want to make sure these pledges and promises actually have teeth to them,” said Consumer Advocate Darryl Lawrence. “What we’re trying to do is get this enshrined in regulation.”
PPL Electric Utilities has forecast more demand from data centers than any other electric company in Pennsylvania. “This is going to be the case that should pretty much set the guiding principles for everyone else,” Consumer Advocate Darryl Lawrence said.
Governor Shapiro intervenes in utility proceeding
Gov. Josh Shapiro’s office filed to intervene as a party in the case, marking the first time in at least 15 years that the governor has taken that step in a utility proceeding.

The intervention gives the Democratic governor an additional avenue to shape data center development rules. In August, Shapiro signed an executive order incentivizing data center developers to secure their own electricity supplies and pay the full cost of required grid upgrades.
Energy experts point out that the political alignment around utility costs is unusual. “There is a level of bipartisan consensus on the idea that Grandma should not be subsidizing Big Tech’s electricity bill that I don’t see in any other facet of American life,” said Abe Silverman, an energy researcher at Johns Hopkins University.
State regulators set cost standard for data center transmission upgrades
Data centers consume power equivalent to thousands or millions of homes, forcing utilities to spend millions upgrading transmission lines. State regulators issued guidance in May establishing a “but for” standard, concluding that data centers should pay for network upgrades that would not be necessary without their interconnection.
However, PPL’s current rules still permit other customers to share increased transmission costs. The consumer advocate’s legal complaint points to a planned $178 million transmission line in Luzerne County needed for a potential data center campus. PPL plans to recover only 12% of that cost from the developer, leaving existing customers to cover the remaining $157 million.
Alex Cutchey, director of state energy policy at the Data Center Coalition, said that member companies including Amazon Web Services, Google, and Microsoft are committed to paying the full cost of serving their facilities to prevent cost-shifting to existing homes and businesses.
Beyond costs, the complaint warns of severe reliability risks. Electricity demand in Pennsylvania remained nearly flat from 2001 to 2024, but demand is now projected to increase by more than 18% by 2030, driven almost entirely by data centers. A report commissioned by state regulators found that worst-case grid shortages could jump from the standard of one event every 10 years to more than 13 shortage events per year starting in 2030.
The utility commission is not due to deliver a final decision on the case until next July.