Providence Committee Advances Plate-Reader Ban, Approves Student Housing Reporting

“Our data is not safe,” a council member said Monday night, explaining why the city should pull the plug on automated license plate readers entirely.

The Providence Special Committee on Health, Opportunity, Prosperity, and Education — known as the HOPE Committee — voted by voice to advance an ordinance that would require the city to immediately deactivate and discontinue all automated license plate readers, Uprise RI reported.

The same committee approved a second measure requiring the city’s colleges to report anonymous, aggregate data on how many students live off campus. Both ordinances now head to the full Providence City Council, which must pass them twice before they reach the mayor’s desk.

The license-plate reader ban targets the Police Department’s network of 60 Flock Safety cameras, deployed across the capital city, WPRI reported. The city’s contract with Flock expires May 16, 2027. Deputy Police Chief Timothy O’Hara opposed the ban before the vote, telling the committee the cameras have assisted “countless criminal investigations.”

Providence Committee Advances Plate-Reader Ban, Approves Student Housing Reporting
Photo: yahoo.com

“We need every legal advantage to keep this city safe,” O’Hara said. “We believe here in Providence we have the proper safeguards in place to protect the confidentiality of our information.”

Deputy Chief Timothy O’Hara, Providence Police Department, to WPRI

Police Chief Oscar Perez echoed that stance in a written statement Monday evening, calling ALPR technology “an important investigative tool” that helps detectives identify vehicles, develop leads, and solve serious crimes. He said the department respects the privacy concerns raised but hopes the city can address them “while preserving access to this valuable technology.”

The Cumberland Lawsuit That Shifted the Debate

Council members who supported the ban cited a federal lawsuit out of Cumberland to argue the cameras capture far more than license plates. According to the committee’s recounting of the suit, a Cumberland officer spotted a gray Volkswagen fail to signal on March 26, 2025; the driver allegedly fled into Attleboro.

Police traced the car to a 73-year-old disabled veteran from South Kingstown, then scoured Facebook friends of someone connected to the vehicle. An officer compared a license-plate-reader image to a woman’s driver’s license photo — an image that apparently showed the person inside the vehicle, not just the plate, Uprise RI reported.

automated license plate readers

The woman was later stopped by another department and arrested on a warrant; she spent more than six hours in custody before charges were dismissed. She is now suing for $750,000, alleging false arrest, malicious prosecution, and negligence. Cumberland denies the allegations and argues officers are protected by qualified immunity.

“There is absolutely nothing cities can do to build 100% confidence that the data will stay with the city,” a committee member said during Monday’s meeting. “But at what cost?”

Providence HOPE Committee member, per Uprise RI

The American Civil Liberties Union of Rhode Island wrote to the committee in strong support of the ordinance, calling it the logical next step after amendments to the city’s Community-Police Relations Act last year.

The ACLU said that six other Rhode Island municipalities — South Kingstown, Narragansett, Glocester, North Kingstown, Foster, and Cumberland — have recently terminated their Flock Safety contracts. It also urged the committee to broaden the ban to cover the six ALPRs owned and operated by the Rhode Island State Police within city limits, WPRI reported.

Providence committee OKs proposed automated license plate reader ban — WPRI

Flock Safety pushed back in a statement to 12 News, saying its cameras have had “a measurable impact on crime in Providence.” The company said violent and property crimes, including homicides and robberies, declined in the last year compared to the year before implementation.

Flock also said its system alerted authorities to 36 missing persons and more than 2,000 stolen license plates and vehicles, and assisted in the search for the Brown University shooting suspect.

Student Housing Data: “You Can’t Make Policy Based on Vibes”

The second ordinance aims to quantify the impact of student housing on neighborhoods. The sponsoring council member said between 7,000 and 10,000 students move off campus annually, a figure driven by growing freshman classes — 1,032 in 2021 and 1,304 this year, the largest on record — and more juniors moving off campus than ever before.

The measure requires schools to report high-level, anonymous counts: no names, student IDs, phone numbers, email addresses, or unit numbers. Asked about enforcement, the sponsor said the draft gives a non-compliant school 30 days to respond after notification; fines were discussed but not finalized.

“You can’t make policy based on vibes,” one committee member said. “Schools should already have the information, so reporting it should be a simple math equation.”

Providence HOPE Committee member, per Uprise RI

Members were told the committee may reconvene before year’s end and were asked to keep their calendars open over the next couple of weeks.