Recount Shifts Three Votes, Jimmie Stephens Keeps Seat After $52,000 Challenge

Jefferson County Commission President Jimmie Stephens kept his seat after a $52,000 recount shifted just three votes, leaving his margin at 392 over Democrat Camara Blue in the District 3 race.

The hand count finished Thursday, more than two weeks after the Nov. 3 general election, and left the outcome exactly where the machine tally had put it. Two votes moved to Blue, one to Stephens, and the incumbent’s lead held, AL.com reported.

“Today’s recount of the Jefferson County Commission District 3 election has once again confirmed the confidence I have always placed in our election process and, more importantly, in the dedicated men and women who administer our elections,” Stephens said in a statement Thursday afternoon.

Blue led for much of election night before Stephens pulled ahead in the final returns, a sequence that left the challenger uneasy. He told WVTM 13 he knew the numbers were unlikely to change but needed the recount for his own peace of mind.

“There were just a few things that just created some unreadiness with me, I just wanted to make sure that everything was what it was, so I requested a recount,” Blue said in an interview with AL.com Thursday afternoon.

Jimmie Stephens is the president of the Jefferson County Commission
Photo: dothaneagle.com

The price tag caught Blue off guard. He said he received inconsistent information from county officials while trying to handle the request, and the final bill — $52,000 — was higher than he expected because officials anticipated a longer process. “I think they caught a lot of people off guard as far as this is not something that just happens all the time,” Blue told AL.com.

“There are some SOPs (standard operating procedures) that come with this so the next person won’t have to go through back and forth and just a bunch of high numbers because they thought it was going to take longer than it did.”

Grassroots donations funded full recount

Blue raised the full amount through grassroots donations. “From day one after the election, I had a huge amount of support from people who wanted to donate to the recount,” he told WVTM 13. “I didn’t get any money from any political party for the recount. It was just people who believed and wanted the same kind of peace of mind.”

Blue said Thursday’s recount process was smooth and respectful.

Jimmie Stephens claims victory after recount changes just 3 votes in Jefferson Co. Commission race — WVTM 13 News

That description contrasted sharply with his earlier frustration over the administrative runaround. By Thursday afternoon, Blue said he was satisfied with the process and accepted the results. He called Stephens to congratulate him. “I’m satisfied with everything that happened today,” Blue told AL.com.

“I’m thankful for the supporters, I’m thankful for the momentum, and I’m just ready. I’m going to take a little break, recoup myself and spend a little time with my wife and my kids and I feel like democracy won today. It was about me just exercising my right as a citizen.”

Stephens: integrity intact, focus returning to governance

Stephens, a decades-long Republican figure in Jefferson County politics, said he never doubted the outcome. “I have never doubted the accuracy of this election or its outcome, and today’s recount only reinforces that confidence,” he said in his statement.

“The citizens of Jefferson County should take great pride in knowing that our election process works and that their votes are counted accurately and fairly.” He added that he does not begrudge Blue for exercising his legal right.

jefferson county recount confirms jimmie stephens win
Photo: wvtm13.com

“Mr. Blue was well served to ask for that recount, and I sincerely hope that he understands that the election process — the integrity of it — is still intact.”

— Jimmie Stephens, Commission President, to WVTM 13

Both men said they are open to working together. Stephens invited Blue’s input on county matters, and Blue told WVTM 13 he plans to keep attending commission meetings. He also said he plans to run again in 2030. After taking a break, Blue plans to continue attending county commission meetings, and he intends to run for commissioner again in 2030.

Stephens, born in 1951 near Bessemer, Alabama, graduated from Samford University with a B.S. in Business Administration and an M.B.A. in 1975. He served on the Bessemer City Council from 2006 to 2010 before winning a Jefferson County Commission seat in a Republican primary runoff and the general election.

He has served continuously since 2010 and has been commission president since 2014, winning re-election unanimously and again in 2018 and 2022. In January 2025, he announced a bid for re-election in 2026.

The episode cost a political newcomer $52,000 and more than two weeks to confirm a 392-vote margin that never budged. Blue intends to run for commissioner again in 2030.