Sonny Gray is open to returning to the Boston Red Sox for the 2027 Major League Baseball season despite his recent departure and a declined $30 million mutual option, Boston Red Sox On SI reported.
The veteran right-handed pitcher posted an 18-5 record with a 2.72 ERA during the 2026 campaign. His strong performance came after he stepped up as the organization’s ace when Garrett Crochet went down with an injury.
Boston’s current rotation balance remains uncertain. On the left-handed side, the Red Sox feature Crochet, Payton Tolle, Ranger Suarez, and Jake Bennet. On the right-handed side, the roster currently lists Brayan Bello, Tanner Houck, and potentially Kutter Crawford.
Clearing the Air After Wild Card Exit
The possibility of Gray’s return stems from a repaired relationship with the front office. Julian McWilliams of CBS Sports reported that Gray reconciled his grievance with the organization after publicly criticizing his early removal from Game 2 of the Wild Card Series against the New York Yankees.
Boston pulled Gray after just 4 2/3 innings in that elimination game. He reached out to team leadership shortly after making his frustrated comments that same evening.
“Starter Sonny Gray reconciled his grievance with the Red Sox after publicly criticizing his early removal from Game 2 of the Wild Card Series,” McWilliams wrote, adding that the right-hander reached out shortly after his comments that evening.
Market Realities and Potential Terms
While Gray is willing to return to Boston, league-wide expectations place him closer to his Nashville home. The Atlanta Braves are viewed as the frontrunners for his services because they have a clear need for starting pitching.
Gray recently turned 37 years old, which could impact the length and total value of his next contract. If his market does not develop into a massive or excessively long deal, a shorter commitment—such as a two-year agreement worth approximately $50 million—could bring him back to Fenway Park.
Offensive Additions in Consideration
Beyond pitching decisions, the front office is evaluating upgrades for the batting order. Chief Baseball Officer Craig Breslow addressed the team’s offensive output during the offseason.

“The offense was inconsistent, and we need to look to find ways to score more runs,” Breslow said.
To address those offensive gaps, Boston has explored multiple avenues, including pursuing star free agent catcher Ryan Jeffers from the Minnesota Twins. Jeffers recorded 21 home runs in a single season and holds a career 109 OPS+. Jon Heyman of NESN reported that the Red Sox emerged as a surprise pursuer for Jeffers following their trade for Adley Rutschman, aiming to build deeper lineup flexibility.