Residents File Lawsuit Over Inner Harbor Redevelopment Plan in Baltimore

A 25-year tax break anchors the Harborplace redevelopment deal announced this week.

The Baltimore Development Corporation agreed on the plan with MCB Real Estate, announcing details on Thursday, setting the stage for the demolition of the two Harborplace pavilions and their replacement with luxury apartments, retail space and new park areas. The agreement includes the lengthy tax incentive, a detail that immediately sharpened the debate over who benefits from the waterfront’s next chapter.

By Friday night, a few dozen opponents gathered 16 floors above the harbor for a $250-per-plate fundraising dinner hosted by the Inner Harbor Coalition. The group is raising money to bankroll legal challenges aimed at slowing the project and forcing the city to reconsider the scope of the development.

Residents File Lawsuit Over Inner Harbor Redevelopment Plan in Baltimore
Photo: wbal.com

“The use, the intensity of development is just wrong,” said Bill Pencek, chair of the Inner Harbor Coalition. “What we are most concerned about is that the project, as well intentioned as we believe Mayor Scott and MCB are, that it is the wrong project for the time.”

Seven residents filed a lawsuit in September arguing the plan would convert public parkland into what Pencek described as “an exclusive community of dwellers, right on the waterfront, in violation of every urban planning principle that has created this harbor.” The coalition contends the pavilions should not be removed until a fully funded, superior replacement is ready to break ground.

“When you have a valuable community asset like the pavilions, the last thing you do is remove them unless and until you’re ready with something better,” Pencek said.

City officials stress that construction cannot begin until MCB proves it has sufficient financing to complete the project. The agreement still requires approval from the City Council and the Board of Estimates, which is scheduled to vote on Dec. 2.

Inner Harbor lawsuit targets Harborplace redevelopment plan — WBAL-TV 11 Baltimore

Reaction at the harbor itself was split. Ethan Goldman, who moved to Baltimore this year, welcomed the change. “Whatever they do to bring it back, I think is going to be kind of a positive thing,” he said.

Benjamin Atkinson, visiting from Pennsylvania, worried the residential focus would overwhelm the area’s character. “You don’t want to put too much emphasis on apartments and everything because it will take away from the rest of the items that are here, the historical stuff,” he said.

Residents File Lawsuit Over Inner Harbor Redevelopment Plan in Baltimore
Photo: wbal.com

Another visitor countered that more residents would improve safety. “I don’t think it would take away because that brings more people and then people feel more comfortable, you know, with it being more people around,” the person said.

The Board of Estimates vote on Dec. 2 represents the next major hurdle for a plan that has been years in the making.