WV Auditor Hunt Sent Demands to City His Office Audits, Report Says

West Virginia Auditor Mark Hunt sent settlement demands to Charleston city officials while his office is responsible for reviewing their financial records every year, West Virginia Watch reported.

The letters arrived between March and July 2026, seeking $11,000 to $15,000 for a woman injured in a crash and the estate of another who died — cases tied to a city his agency is required by law to review every year for solvency, accounting errors and purchasing-card compliance across all 232 municipalities.

Charleston Mayor Amy Goodwin’s chief of staff, Matt Sutton, called it a conflict of interest that puts taxpayers at risk. “We believe it is a conflict of interest and any negotiation involving public funds with the state auditor in a legal matter would not be in the best interest of the taxpayers of the City of Charleston,” Sutton told West Virginia Watch.

Two ethics opinions, one state seal

Hunt, a personal injury attorney with more than 30 years of practice in the Kanawha Valley, said he holds two opinions from the state Ethics Commission clearing him to serve as full-time auditor and part-time lawyer, including representing clients against Charleston.

“Have 2 State Ethics opinions that say OK to be full time Auditor and part time lawyer,” Hunt wrote in an email to West Virginia Watch. The commission did not respond to the outlet’s request for confirmation.

WV Auditor Hunt Sent Demands to City His Office Audits, Report Says
Photo: yahoo.com

One March email exchange about a client carried the official seal of the Auditor’s Office. Hunt dismissed it as a private Outlook account. “Private email, don’t know how they got it? I only use it between friends. It’s a free outlook email. I did not correspond with them on it other than 2 words. ‘Thank you.’”

Audit letter

Weeks after Hunt’s first demand letter, the Auditor’s Office sent a notice to the Kanawha County prosecutor flagging findings in Charleston’s latest audit — a step the city had not seen since at least 2019, according to records obtained by West Virginia Watch.

The letter said the office did not believe the findings warranted civil or criminal action but cited state code requiring notification when a law may have been violated.

Hunt said he is insulated from that division. “Chief inspector runs own ship. I am not informed on minor audit findings.”

WV Auditor Hunt Sent Demands to City His Office Audits, Report Says
Photo: wvmetronews.com

City takes concerns to the Attorney General

Charleston officials brought the matter to Attorney General JB McCuskey. “We reached out and provided information to the attorney general, and others, to determine the best course of action to move forward,” Sutton said. “Based on that guidance, we took the appropriate steps until the parties notified us of new legal representation.” McCuskey declined to comment. Hunt confirmed he no longer represents the plaintiffs; neither case became a lawsuit.

Widening perimeter of scrutiny

Gov. Patrick Morrisey said he directed the Division of Motor Vehicles to refer findings from a month-long investigation into Hunt’s used-car lot, After Hours Used Auto, to the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia.

The DMV suspended the dealership’s license after identifying “significant and unexplained anomalies in the dealership’s paperwork that implicate a number of potential violations of state and federal laws, including DMV and tax laws,” Morrisey said.

The Office of Lawyer Disciplinary Counsel confirmed an open complaint against Hunt, though it would not disclose details. David Cole, Hunt’s deputy chief of staff and marketing manager at his law firm, was also named in the federal indictment. Del.

Tristan Leavitt, R-Kanawha, said the mounting issues would factor into House impeachment proceedings if Hunt does not resign. “West Virginia has ethics laws directly addressing this issue and they would undoubtedly factor into House impeachment proceedings if Mark Hunt doesn’t resign,” Leavitt said.

Cynthia Brown, senior ethics counsel at Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, called the overlap questionable. “Hunt has already violated the public’s trust by apparently abusing the power of his office, giving them reason to question whether there was any impropriety in the overlap between his private personal injury practice and official duties,” she said.

Hunt has maintained his innocence and pledged to stay in office. “Office running smoothly, up $23 million this year alone,” he wrote Thursday. “Once again I checked with all appropriate officials before doing anything.”