SC Declared RA 12021 Section 59 Unconstitutional on Seafarers’ Bond Rule

Associate Justice Maria Filomena D declared RA 12021 Section 59 unconstitutional regarding seafarers' bond rule.

“They already lack money to buy medicine. Where would they get the money for a bond?”

Senator Risa Hontiveros asked during the Senate debates on the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers. On November 11, the Supreme Court agreed, striking down the bond requirement that had blocked injured seafarers from collecting monetary awards while their employers appealed.

The high court, sitting en banc, declared Section 59 of Republic Act No. 12021 unconstitutional in a decision penned by Associate Justice Maria Filomena D. Singh. The provision had forced seafarers to post a bond before executing disputed monetary awards and damages pending appeal or judicial review — a financial burden imposed on no other category of Filipino worker.

The ruling also voided the use of the Department of Migrant Workers’ AKSYON Fund to pay bond premiums, ruling that public funds cannot serve private interests, and struck down a 10 percent cap on lawyers’ fees as an intrusion on the Court’s exclusive authority over the practice of law.

The bond that broke the worker

Under the Magna Carta, which took effect in October 2024, wages, statutory benefits and undisputed amounts were immediately executory. But disputed awards — often covering disability or death claims — required a bond guaranteeing repayment if the award was later reversed.

“This law has been in place for two years. Many seafarers need compensation for their injuries, but they cannot get it because of this law,” former Bayan Muna Representative Neri Colmenares, legal counsel for the Concerned Seafarers of the Philippines, said at a press conference in Manila on Friday. Colmenares told the Inquirer that the requirement effectively prevented injured seafarers from accessing compensation even after winning their labor cases.

The Court acknowledged the government’s interest in preventing “ambulance chasing” and protecting the maritime industry against unrecoverable awards. But it concluded those objectives did not justify the financial requirement. The justices found the bond rule violated due process and equal protection because it singled out seafarers for a burden not placed on other workers.

The ruling also invalidated Section 1, Rule XXII of the Department of Labor and Employment’s Department Order No. 247, Series of 2025, which implemented the bond mechanism, declaring it ultra vires — beyond the agency’s authority.

SC junks bond requirement for seafarers who won labor cases — IBC DIGITAL (OFFICIAL IBC TV 13)

What survives, what falls

The decision partially granted five consolidated petitions challenging the Magna Carta and its implementing rules. While the bond provision, the AKSYON Fund mechanism, the 10 percent fee cap, and related rules on notarized certifications and fee collection were voided, the Court upheld key provisions on maritime education and training — Sections 75, 76 and 78 — rejecting challenges to the legislative process and the transfer of regulatory authority to the Maritime Industry Authority.

The Magna Carta remains valid and enforceable except for the provisions expressly declared unconstitutional or void.

“Sa wakas, may pasya na! Dalawang isyu ang inilapit namin sa Korte Suprema, at sa pareho ay nanaig ang mga marino. Tagumpay ito ng mga manggagawa, lalo na ng marinong umuwing may pinsala at ng pamilyang naghihintay ng pambili ng gamot.”

Sonny Matula, national president of the Federation of Free Workers, told Philstar.com

Matula, whose federation was among the petitioners, urged President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and the Office of the Solicitor General not to seek reconsideration so the ruling could attain finality without delay. He also called on DOLE to revise its implementing rules to remove provisions that conflict with the decision, giving labor arbiters, voluntary arbitrators, workers and employers clear guidance on executing compensation awards.

Colmenares echoed the demand, urging the National Labor Relations Commission, the National Conciliation and Mediation Board, and DOLE to execute pending compensation awards dating back to the law’s effectivity. “Execute all pending compensation awards from the time the law took effect. Do not make it difficult or prolong the process. Seafarers have been waiting for two years,” he said.

Seafarers' advocates seek Magna Carta reforms despite SC victory
Photo: Daily Tribune

Lawyer Dennis Gorecho of the International Pro Bono Alliance warned that gaps remain. He told the Daily Tribune that workers undergoing training, completing recruitment requirements or awaiting deployment could fall outside the law’s coverage, leaving them vulnerable to abuse.

The advocates also pressed the government to act on pending complaints against lawyers accused of “ambulance chasing” under the Seafarers Protection Act (Republic Act No. 10706), which prohibits the practice under Section 3 and provides penalties under Section 5. Matula argued those responsible for abusive practices should be held accountable instead of imposing restrictions that also affect workers seeking legitimate legal assistance.

The full text of the decision has yet to be released on the Supreme Court website. As of Friday, Malacañang had not commented on whether the Solicitor General would file a motion for reconsideration.