Seattle Gas Station Clerk Killing Suspect Booked in King County Jail After Arrest in Chicago

A 33-year-old man accused of killing a Seattle gas station clerk and suspected of murdering his mother and her husband in Wisconsin was booked into King County Jail on Tuesday, ending a weeks-long interstate manhunt.

Michael O’Neal Fleming was arrested by U.S. marshals in Chicago on Oct. 20, one week after Seattle police found Graeme Dobbeck, 36, dead inside the 76 station at Denny Way and Broad Street, the Seattle Times reported. The arrest came one day after Kenosha, Wis., police discovered Rena O’Neal, 59, and Rodney Brushwood, 57, fatally shot in their home during a welfare check.

King County prosecutors charged Fleming in absentia with first-degree murder with a firearm enhancement and requested $5 million bail. He is scheduled to enter a plea at his arraignment on Monday, said Casey McNerthney, a spokesperson for the prosecuting attorney’s office.

“The suspect appears to walk with a ‘knock-kneed’ gait, meaning his legs came together at the knees, and his lower legs spanned outward.”

Surveillance captures calculated movements

Security video from the morning of Oct. 13 shows Fleming circling the locked 76 station around 4:30 a.m. before walking to a nearby 7-Eleven, moving between the two stores for roughly 30 minutes, according to charging documents cited by the Chronline.

He entered the 76 station after 5 a.m. The recording captured the clerk saying “good morning” twice. Fleming did not respond. He grabbed a drink, took it to the counter, and as Dobbeck scanned it, walked to the clerk’s doorway and fired a handgun four times from one to two feet away.

Seattle Gas Station Clerk Killing Suspect Booked in King County Jail After Arrest in Chicago
Photo: chronline.com

The cash register was open, displaying coins and a large stack of $20 bills. One bill lay on the counter; several coins were on the floor. Cracks in a glass window suggested fresh bullet impacts. Fleming walked out toward Broad Street, not in any apparent hurry, and took no money.

Fred Forrest, a customer stopping for coffee around 6 a.m., noticed the security door behind the counter open and a stool tipped over. He walked behind the counter and found Dobbeck on the ground surrounded by blood. He called 911. Police responded within minutes.

Four years of employment, no clear motive

Fleming had worked at 76 stations owned by the same employer for four years, including the Broad Street location, the Chronline reported. He submitted his two weeks’ notice in September and worked his final shift on Oct. 2. The owner told investigators Fleming left with “no unusual dynamics.” The final text messages between Fleming and Dobbeck were routine business discussions about a fuel receipt.

Court filings note Fleming had no criminal convictions in King County Superior Court. Prosecutors and police wrote they found no motive to explain why he allegedly killed his former manager.

According to the affidavit, Fleming’s twin brother informed investigators that recent text messages from Fleming were erratic and delusional, and that he appeared to be experiencing a mental health crisis. The brother said their mother had texted that Fleming was in Chicago. Before the shooting, Fleming asked his brother for their parents’ address, which he refused to provide.

Seattle Gas Station Clerk Killing Suspect Booked in King County Jail After Arrest in Chicago
Photo: yahoo.com

Trail leads from Seattle hotel to Wisconsin

Detectives traced Fleming to the Ontario Hotel on Airport Way South, where he had lived in different units since 2021. The hotel owner said Fleming informed staff on Oct. 13 — the day of the Seattle shooting — that he planned to move out and board a flight to an unspecified destination.

A search of his unit yielded one .38-caliber fired cartridge casing and round. Court records show he was the registered owner of four handguns.

On Oct. 19, Kenosha police conducted a welfare check after an employee reported their boss had not been seen for days. They found O’Neal and Brushwood dead from multiple gunshot wounds, dead for days. They were identified as Fleming’s mother and her husband, who was not Fleming’s father.

Arraignment set for Monday

Fleming agreed to be transported back to Washington. He was booked Tuesday night into King County Jail, where he remains held on $5 million bail. His arraignment is scheduled for Monday.