SI, NYT Predict Nebraska to End Ranked Skid, Upset Ohio State 20-17 on Final Field Goal

Nebraska ends its 31-game skid against ranked opponents on a walk-off field goal Saturday in Lincoln, handing Ohio State a 20-17 loss that scrambles the Big Ten championship picture and the College Football Playoff at-large race.

The Cornhuskers entered Week 12 at 3-4 in conference play but fifth nationally in net success rate and 21st in adjusted net EPA per play, underlying metrics that Sports Illustrated flagged as the signature of a “wasted opportunity for something special.”

Ohio State arrived 1-2 over its last three games; Luke Fahey threw for just 201 yards with a turnover against Northwestern, and the Buckeyes were without starting quarterback Will Howard for the second straight week.

Anthony Colandrea converted a critical third-and-7 with his legs on the final drive, setting up a 42-yard field goal as time expired. The victory snaps a drought that stretched back to 2016 and comes one week after Nebraska lost to Indiana by three points and to Oregon by three.

The metrics that liked Nebraska all along

Sports Illustrated’s Iain MacMillan wrote that Nebraska ranked 21st in adjusted net EPA per play and fifth in net success rate entering the week, numbers that outperformed the 3-4 record. The Huskers’ defense leads the nation on third down and held Indiana to 20 points and Oregon to 17.

SI, NYT Predict Nebraska to End Ranked Skid, Upset Ohio State 20-17 on Final Field Goal
Photo: si.com

The New York Times’ prediction column framed the matchup as a clash between those advanced metrics and Ohio State’s talent edge, particularly freshman receiver Jeremiah Smith, the nation’s top pass catcher. Nebraska lost cornerback Andrew Marshall this week, a blow the Times called “a lousy way to get ready for Smith.”

Loss likely knocks Ohio State out of top 12

Fahey’s limited production — 201 yards and a turnover against Northwestern — mirrored the broader instability at the position since Howard’s injury. The Buckeyes had climbed six spots in the CFP rankings after teams ahead of them lost, re-entering the at-large conversation. Saturday’s loss likely knocks them out of the top 12 and complicates the committee’s task of explaining why four 6-4 SEC teams remain ranked.

The Times column had projected a 20-17 Nebraska win on the final-play field goal, a scenario that played out almost exactly as scripted. The same column went 7-2 straight up and 5-4 against the spread in Week 11, bringing the season record to 59-40 straight up and 46-49-4 ATS.

Week 12’s other moving parts

The upset picked by both outlets — Nebraska over Ohio State — was one of three major underdog plays Sports Illustrated highlighted. SI also backed Vanderbilt (+440) over Florida and Washington (+245) over Indiana, citing Florida’s 122nd-ranked defensive success rate and Washington’s 28th-ranked defensive success rate as analytical edges. The Times projected Indiana to beat Washington 27-17 behind Charlie Becker’s 36-yard fourth-quarter touchdown and a subsequent interception.

Nebraska has sold out every home game at Memorial Stadium since 1962, a streak that began under Bob Devaney, who was hired that year and won national championships in 1970 and 1971.

Tom Osborne succeeded Devaney in 1973 and over twenty-five seasons his teams never won fewer than nine games and were ranked for 304 of 307 games, adding titles in 1994, 1995 and 1997 before the program endured its worst eight-year stretch in over sixty years under Mike Riley and Scott Frost prior to Matt Rhule’s 2023 arrival.

The Cornhuskers' win keeps them alive for a bowl berth and delivers the program's biggest moment since 2016. The Buckeyes, meanwhile, face a shortened week to stabilize the quarterback room before the regular-season finale with everything still technically on the table.