Two Alaska House Races Separated by Three and Four Votes After Ranked Choice Tabulation

Two Alaska House races in the Matanuska-Susitna Borough are separated by three and four votes after Wednesday’s ranked choice tabulation, leaving the state’s fastest-growing districts in a statistical dead heat.

The margins are small enough to trigger automatic state-funded recounts.

The Alaska Division of Elections ran its preliminary ranked choice calculations Wednesday, adding more than 6,000 ballots — mostly from the Mat-Su — to the statewide total, Alaska Beacon reported. In House District 30, Republican candidate Doug Massie is leading Republican Rep. Kevin McCabe by three votes. Next door in House District 29, incumbent Rep. Garret Nelson leads Republican challenger Steve Menard by four votes.

The results cement a legislative picture that looks markedly different from two years ago. Independents have won seven of the 40 House seats, Democrats 17 and Republicans 16, according to Wednesday’s preliminary totals. That is a five-seat swing from the 21 Republicans who won in 2024, and it means the House will again be run by a multipartisan coalition of Republicans, Democrats and independents.

The Senate, where 10 of 20 seats were on the ballot this year, will be governed by an 11-member coalition majority: Republicans hold 11 seats, Democrats nine, and independent Sen.-elect Bryce Edgmon of Dillingham holds one.

How Democratic voters swung two Republican-on-Republican races

The Mat-Su’s closest contests turned on how Democratic-leaning voters ranked their second and third choices after their preferred candidates were eliminated. In House District 30, which covers the western Mat-Su and the Denali Borough, McCabe led Massie in first-choice votes. But when Democratic candidate Sandra Loomis was eliminated, nearly a fifth of her voters ranked Massie next — enough to flip a narrow deficit into a three-vote lead.

Two Alaska House Races Separated by Three and Four Votes After Ranked Choice Tabulation
Photo: yahoo.com

In House District 29, covering the eastern Mat-Su, Nelson led Menard by fewer than 50 first-choice votes. The small number of Democratic-leaning voters who ranked either Republican split their second choices evenly, allowing Nelson to hold his four-vote edge.

A similar dynamic played out in House District 28, where Rep. Elexie Moore trailed Republican Stephen Wright in first choices but finished ahead of Democratic candidate Kit Kennedy. When Kennedy was eliminated, most of her supporters declined to rank either Republican; a small plurality chose Moore, but not enough to overcome Wright’s 46-vote margin.

“Voters who backed Democratic candidate Sandra Loomis strongly favored Massie once Loomis was eliminated,” the Division of Elections’ preliminary data shows. The transfer rates in these districts illustrate how Alaska’s nonpartisan primary and ranked choice general election system can produce outcomes that diverge sharply from first-choice tallies.

Recounts loom as certification deadline approaches

Alaska law provides for a state-funded recount when the margin is 20 votes or fewer, or less than 0.5% of the total votes cast for the two leading candidates. The request can come from a candidate or 10 qualified voters in the district. McCabe said by text message that he intends to request a recount in House District 30. It was not immediately clear whether Menard would do the same in House District 29.

The Division of Elections does not perform its official ranked choice runoff until November 18, the deadline for the last international absentee ballots to arrive, but it publishes preliminary data that allows observers to conduct their own unofficial tabulations using open-source software such as RCTab. Races will be certified November 25, after which recounts can proceed.

Berry defeats appointed incumbent Tilton in Senate District M

In Senate District M, covering Wasilla, Republican Ryan Berry defeated appointed incumbent Sen. Cathy Tilton by 467 votes in a ranked choice runoff. Berry gained ground when Republican Zane Vrvilo was eliminated, and extended his lead further when Democratic candidate Pat Chesbro was eliminated and her voters’ second choices broke toward Berry. Gov. Mike Dunleavy had appointed Tilton to replace Sen. Mike Shower after he resigned to run for lieutenant governor.

Sen. George Rauscher, also a Dunleavy appointee replacing Sen. Shelley Hughes after she resigned to run for governor, won his own term in a ranked choice runoff. In Kodiak, Republican Rep. Louise Stutes won a three-way Republican contest to replace retiring Sen. Gary Stevens, finishing with 49.9% of first-choice votes — just shy of the 50% threshold that would have avoided a runoff.

Johnson edges Vance by 59 votes in House District 6

Independent Brent Johnson defeated Republican Rep. Sarah Vance by 59 votes out of 10,128 cast in House District 6, a race that remained unresolved until Wednesday because of late-counted absentee ballots. In Anchorage, Republican Rep. Julie Coulombe held off Democratic challenger Danni Hall by 131 votes in House District 11, while Democratic candidate Denny Wells unseated Republican Rep. Mia Costello in House District 15 by 669 votes.

In Eagle River, Republican Rep. Jamie Allard won re-election in a four-way ranked choice runoff after leading in first-choice votes.

Former Rep. Ken McCarty returned to the House in District 24, defeating moderate Republican Gina Wall by 52 votes in a two-candidate race that still required ranked choice tabulation because neither candidate cleared 50% and more than 100 write-in votes were cast. Rep. DeLena Johnson of Palmer and Rep. Mike Prax of North Pole both won re-election after three-way ranked choice runoffs.

In rural districts, Democratic Rep. Nellie Unangiq Jimmie won re-election in House District 38 with 58.2% in the final tabulation, ahead of former Democratic Rep. CJ McCormick. Democratic Rep. Neal Foster won in House District 39 after a ranked choice runoff, with independent Tyler Ivanoff finishing second. Evelynn Trefon won the open House District 37 seat with 58.8%, replacing Edgmon, who moved to the Senate.

The Matanuska-Susitna Borough, whose population reached 107,081 in the 2020 census, is the state’s fastest-growing subdivision, up from 88,995 in 2010. It spans 25,258 square miles and contains the entire Matanuska and Susitna Rivers, making it one of Alaska’s few agricultural areas.

Certification is scheduled for November 25. The recount requests, if filed, will determine whether the final margins in Districts 29 and 30 hold — or whether the Mat-Su’s legislative delegation shifts by a handful of votes.