Montana just sent a U.S. senator to Washington with less than half the vote — again.
In November’s four-way Senate race, Republican Kurt Alme won with 48 percent while a majority of voters split their ballots among three other candidates.
It was the third time this century a Montana Senate seat went to a candidate most voters opposed, according to a new analysis from the Sightline Institute, a nonpartisan think tank based in the Pacific Northwest. The culprit is the state’s plurality-winner rule: whoever gets the most votes wins, even if 52 percent of the electorate wanted someone else.
“Parties by no means have to cross-nominate candidates, but the practice can create win-win scenarios when they do,” Sightline researcher Al Vanderklipp wrote in the report released this week. He argues the state has two proven remedies sitting in its own history books — fusion voting and top-two primaries — plus models from other states that use runoff elections.
The 2026 migraine
The race played out like a case study in vote-splitting chaos. Former Senator Jon Tester, a Democrat, reportedly called his party’s brand “poison” and backed independent Seth Bodnar, the former University of Montana president. Tester allies then boosted Alani Bankhead in the Democratic primary, perhaps hoping she would step aside for Bodnar. She refused.
On the Republican side, incumbent Steve Daines swapped out of the primary at the last minute for Alme, who cruised to the nomination. Libertarian Kyle Austin, running at odds with his own party, rounded out a field where the three non-GOP candidates collectively outpolled the winner — but divided the anti-Alme vote enough to hand him the seat.
A decade of shadow boxing
The 2026 race wasn’t an anomaly. It was the latest round in a long-running brawl where both major parties treat minor-party candidates as weapons rather than competitors.
In 2024, Donald Trump publicly pressured Libertarian Sid Daoud to drop out of the Senate race. Democrats sued to remove Green Party candidate Robert Barb from the ballot after he received Republican backing. In 2022, Democratic nominee Monica Tranel held joint forums with Libertarian John Lamb in the western congressional district, prompting right-wing outlets to accuse them of colluding to spoil the election.
In 2020, Republicans quietly funded a $100,000 signature drive to qualify Green Party candidates — without telling the voters who signed the petitions. In 2018, Democrats challenged the Green Party’s ballot status in court. Dark money mailers tried to boost Libertarian Rick Breckenridge in the Senate race that year to help Tester.
“Rather than trying to tailor campaigns to a majority of Montanans, Democratic and Republican heavyweights seem stuck in a never-ending tug-of-war over candidates who might spoil close contests for the other major party,” Vanderklipp wrote.
Montana used fusion voting in the 1890s
Montana doesn’t need to look far for fixes. The state used fusion voting in the 1890s. When Republican John E. Rickards won the governor’s office with just over 40 percent in 1892, Democrats and Populists fused behind Robert B. Smith four years later and took 72 percent.
The practice lets two or more parties nominate the same candidate, pooling their ballot lines and voter bases. It’s legal in a handful of states today, including New York and Connecticut, but Montana would have to reauthorize it.
The other homegrown option is already on the books for nonpartisan races. Montana’s judicial elections use a top-two primary: if three or more candidates run, only the top two advance to November. That guaranteed majority winners in both Supreme Court seats on the ballot in 2024.
California and Washington apply the same model to partisan races — all candidates on one primary ballot, top two advance regardless of party. Since adopting top-two, one in seven legislative primaries in those states has produced a same-party general election, giving voters a real choice in districts the other party doesn’t contest.
Montana legislators have introduced top-two bills in 2013, 2015, 2023, and 2025. None passed.
Runoff models from the South and West
Other states take a different approach. Georgia and Mississippi hold delayed runoffs weeks after the general election if no one clears 50 percent. The model has a fraught history — it was designed by segregationist Democrats to maintain one-party rule — and it still suffers from low turnout, high cost, and administrative strain.
Louisiana’s version is cleaner. Most state offices skip partisan primaries entirely. Everyone runs together in November, and a runoff happens only if no one hits a majority. Researchers credit the system with reducing polarization and improving governance, though the legislature moved congressional races to partisan primaries in 2024 over objections.
Alaska and Maine skip the second election day altogether with instant runoffs, better known as ranked-choice voting. Voters rank candidates; if no one wins a majority of first choices, the last-place candidate is eliminated and their voters’ second choices are redistributed until someone crosses 50 percent.
Despite partisan attacks, the method doesn’t favor either party — it just ensures the winner beats the strongest opponent head-to-head. Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Louisiana, Mississippi, and South Carolina all use ranked ballots for military voters in runoff elections, a quiet bipartisan endorsement of the mechanics.
The 2027 choice
When the legislature reconvenes in 2027, lawmakers will face the same menu they’ve declined for years: fusion voting, top-two primaries, delayed runoffs, or instant runoffs. Any of them would make it unlikely that a candidate opposed by most voters wins a Senate seat.
Sightline Institute, founded in 1993 by Alan Durning as Northwest Environment Watch, is a nonpartisan research center based in Seattle that focuses on sustainability policy across the Pacific Northwest. Its democracy program, which produced the Montana analysis, has also backed legislation in Washington to modernize conservation district elections and strengthen local representation.
None of these systems would have guaranteed a different outcome in 2006, 2012, or 2026 — Tester or Alme might still have won head-to-head. But Montanans would at least know their senator had majority support.