Six Former Iowa State Players Allege Abuse Pattern, Demand Independent Review

Six former Iowa State women’s basketball players went public with a joint statement alleging a pattern of verbal, emotional and psychological abuse under coach Bill Fennelly, escalating a conflict that began with his one-game suspension for “inappropriate contact” with a current player on Nov. 15.

The statement, distributed by attorney Lori Bullock, names Maggie Espenmiller-McGraw and Izabella Zingaro alongside four unnamed former teammates. They describe an environment where “intimidation, humiliation, and fear became normalized” and say concerns raised to coaching staff and athletic administration were not taken seriously.

“We accepted the demands of hard work, discipline, and competitive excellence. But demanding excellence is fundamentally different from undermining an athlete’s dignity, well-being, and sense of safety,” the players wrote. “For some of us, the consequences did not end with our playing careers. We continue to deal with anxiety, depression, diminished self-worth, and lasting distress that we associate with our time in the program.”

Six Former Iowa State Players Allege Abuse Pattern, Demand Independent Review
Photo: kcrg.com

Espenmiller-McGraw, an Indianola native who played from 2019 to 2023 before transferring, and Zingaro, a team member from 2020 to 2023 who also transferred, are the only two players willing to be identified publicly. The statement says they speak for themselves and four others who shared stories but are not ready to be named.

Suspension triggers wider reckoning

Fennelly, who has coached the Cyclones since 1995 and is set to retire after the 2026-27 season, served a one-game suspension after athletic director Jared Benko announced he had made “inappropriate contact” with a player during a timeout.

The players’ statement thanks Benko for “swift attention and immediate action” but argues a single suspension does not resolve what they call a pattern spanning almost ten years. The university declined to comment on the broader allegations.

Former ISU women’s basketball players call for independent review of program — KCRG-TV9: Your Trusted Local News Source

The former players are demanding four specific actions: an independent, trauma-informed review of the program and the university’s handling of past complaints; protection against retaliation and a confidential process for current and former athletes; public acknowledgment of the seriousness of the concerns with mental and physical health support for affected players; and a commitment to transparent, lasting reforms in student-athlete welfare.

History of prior complaint

This is not the first time Fennelly’s conduct has drawn formal scrutiny. In 2017, former guard Nikki Moody sued Fennelly, Iowa State and the state of Iowa for racial discrimination, alleging she was repeatedly called a “thug” and labeled a selfish player. The lawsuit was settled for $60,000; Fennelly was dismissed from the suit before the settlement.

AMES, IOWA - NOVEMBER 15: Head coach Bill Fennelly of the Iowa State Cyclones looks on during the second quarter against
Photo: kcci.com

“Winning does not excuse mistreatment. Loyalty to a program should never require silence. And protecting student-athletes must always outweigh protecting a reputation,” the joint statement concludes. It directs anyone seeking support or wishing to share an experience to contact Bullock at Bullock Law PLLC or call or text 988.