Six nurses told Maine health regulators Thursday that Prime Healthcare’s firing and suspension of experienced staff has degraded patient care at Central Maine Medical Center, violating the conditions the state attached to the hospital chain’s takeover earlier this year.
The testimony came at a Department of Health and Human Services hearing in Auburn, part of the agency’s review of whether Prime is honoring the Certificate of Need it received April 2. That approval, granted after Prime completed its acquisition on Feb. 16, required the for-profit chain to maintain existing services at the Lewiston hospital.
“Maintaining services means maintaining safe levels of staff,” said Katie Grinnell, a registered nurse who worked at CMMC for five and a half years before Prime fired her this summer. “Prime has pushed out experienced staff members who are very difficult to replace in a rural area, leading to reduced access to services for patients.”
Grinnell said Prime fired or suspended 20 nurses at CMMC for advocating for patients, including seven of the 14 nurses in the infusion unit, a loss that immediately reduced the level of care that unit could provide. She called on the state to require Prime to reinstate the terminated nurses and restore safe staffing levels throughout the hospital.
“Since the takeover, we have seen increased patient loads, shortages of basic supplies, and cuts that make it harder to do our jobs safely,” said Aaron McDaniel, an ICU nurse at CMMC who was suspended by Prime. His written comments were read aloud at the hearing because he could not attend.
“I saw this firsthand during one of my last shifts before I was suspended. An ICU patient urgently needed medication through a drip, but we had run short of the necessary tubing. Supplies had been reduced, and there was no Sunday restocking. I had to leave the unit and search for what the patient needed — putting my patient’s life at risk. These are not minor inconveniences. They directly affect patient care and lessen the number of patients and service levels we are able to provide.”
Cyndi Gahagan, Mariah Pfieffer, Christina Beckwith and Paul Silva, all registered nurses at CMMC, also testified at the hearing. DHHS will accept written comments on the Certificate of Need review until Nov. 30.
The dispute has been building since spring. Nurses at CMMC and at Prime’s Olympia Fields Hospital in Illinois filed union election petitions with the National Nurses Organizing Committee on Aug. 24.
By Sept. 3, nurses at four Prime hospitals across three states — West Anaheim Medical Center in California, Saint Mary’s Regional Medical Center in Nevada, Saint Mary of Nazareth Hospital in Chicago and Shasta Regional Medical Center in California — held one-day strikes over staffing and patient-care concerns. Nurses at Saint Mary of Nazareth had voted to join NNOC in June.
Tensions escalated in mid-September. On Sept. 15, Olympia Fields nurses struck to protest retaliation against nurses who spoke up, while CMMC and Saint Mary of Nazareth nurses held informational pickets in solidarity. Sympathy strikes followed at Prime hospitals in Reno, Anaheim and Redding. Olympia Fields nurses voted overwhelmingly to join NNOC on Sept. 23; CMMC nurses won their MSNA/NNOC union election in a landslide the next day.
Since then, pressure from nurses and the public has forced a handful of reinstatements: three Olympia Fields nurses on Oct. 2, a fourth on Oct. 5, and one CMMC nurse on Oct. 30. CMMC nurses held a town hall in Auburn on Nov. 17 to rally opposition to Prime’s management ahead of Thursday’s hearing.
The Maine State Nurses Association, part of the National Nurses Organizing Committee, represents about 4,000 nurses and caregivers from Portland to Fort Kent. NNOC is an affiliate of National Nurses United, the largest union of registered nurses in the United States with more than 225,000 members nationwide.
Prime Healthcare, the for-profit chain that acquired Central Maine Medical Center in February, was founded in 2001 by Prem Reddy and is headquartered in Ontario, California. By 2026 it operated 55 acute-care hospitals in 15 states, with more than 60,000 employees and physicians and over 8,700 patient beds.
Twenty-one of those hospitals are run through its not-for-profit subsidiary, Prime Healthcare Foundation. The company has a history of disputes with insurers and regulators, including a 2010 federal investigation into unusually high sepsis billing rates at several of its facilities.
DHHS has not indicated when it will rule on whether Prime is in compliance with its Certificate of Need. The agency accepts comments by mail at 11 State House Station, 41 Anthony Avenue, Augusta, Maine 04333-0011, or by email at [email protected].