Judge Orders Regents to Clear Godfrey; NCAA Warns Arizona

“The NCAA has refused to engage with Arizona,” Godfrey’s attorneys wrote in an emergency motion filed Wednesday evening, “because of its position that he is already ineligible because he played four years already.”

Pima County Superior Court Judge Jeffrey Bergin ordered the Arizona Board of Regents to certify forward RJ Godfrey eligible on Tuesday, but the NCAA is ignoring the injunction and threatening the university if he plays, Arizona Daily Star reported. The standoff leaves the 6-foot-8 Clemson transfer sidelined for the Wildcats’ marquee matchup against No. 3 UConn on Wednesday night at McKale Center.

RJ Godfrey Unavailable Again for Arizona Amid Ongoing Eligibility Dispute — KGUN9

Godfrey averaged 12.0 points, 5.3 rebounds and 1.5 assists last season for the Tigers. His arrival was supposed to give coach Tommy Lloyd a rugged, physical rebounder who fits perfectly next to center Mo Krivas and allows Ivan Kharchenkov to slide to his natural small forward spot.

Without him, Arizona turns to freshmen Maksim Brnovic and Ugnius Jarusevicius alongside transfer Evan Otten against a UConn frontcourt anchored by Seton Hall transfer Najai Hines and Stanford transfer Oskar Giltay.

The case turns on a novel legal theory. Instead of suing the NCAA directly — the route that failed in Georgia and spawned the Chauncey Wiggins precedent at Gonzaga — Godfrey sued the Arizona Board of Regents for breach of contract.

His attorneys argue the NCAA’s own manual says member institutions determine eligibility, so the university must clear him regardless of the association’s stance. Bergin granted a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction Tuesday. The Board of Regents complied immediately. The NCAA did not.

The NCAA’s counterplay

NCAA outside counsel Rakesh Kilaru told the university in an email that Godfrey remains ineligible “despite his forum-shopping attempts” because he is still a party to the Georgia five-for-five case and because the NCAA is a defendant in a similar Pima County suit involving two Arizona football players. The association warned that if Arizona “permits Godfrey to compete, it does so at its own risk.”

Bergin pushed back on the emergency motion Wednesday. He wrote that Godfrey’s frustration “appears to stem not from actions taken by the Defendant but from the continued inaction of the non-party NCAA,” and that a motion to enforce “is not a vehicle to enlarge the substance of an injunction or to obtain additional relief that was neither requested nor granted in the underlying order.”

Judge Orders Regents to Clear Godfrey; NCAA Warns Arizona
Photo: si.com

A high-stakes gamble

Godfrey’s attorneys are expected to ask Bergin to hold the NCAA in contempt. If the judge complies, the association would face sanctions for defying a court order it was not technically a party to — a constitutional collision between judicial authority and the NCAA’s claim of private governance. If Bergin declines, Godfrey’s season likely ends before it starts.

The Arizona Board of Regents, which governs the state’s three public universities, traces its authority to an 1885 territorial law creating the University of Arizona. A 1945 statute unified control of the Tempe and Flagstaff colleges under the board, placing Arizona State University and Northern Arizona University alongside the Tucson campus.

The board is a constitutionally created body corporate existing on a plane equivalent to the legislature; the universities have no independent legal existence but are extensions of the board. Its ten voting members include eight gubernatorial appointees serving staggered eight-year terms, plus the governor and the superintendent of public instruction as ex officio members.

The Wildcats tip off against the Huskies at 7:15 p.m. MST on FS1. Godfrey will watch in street clothes.