Attorney General Marty Jackley closed the book Friday on criminal allegations against the South Dakota Investment Council, marking the third entity with investigative authority to find no evidence of wrongdoing in the management of the state’s more than $20 billion in assets.
The announcement ends a months-long review triggered by former Senior Investment Manager Renae Randall, who argued her 2025 firing was retaliation for flagging errors in the council’s primary asset-allocation model. Jackley’s office concluded her complaints center on disagreements over investment strategy, personnel decisions and management practices — not criminal conduct.
“When individuals bring credible evidence of potential criminal activity to our office, we will investigate those allegations thoroughly,” Jackley said in a news release. “After reviewing the materials provided in this matter, we found no evidence of criminal conduct.”
The Department of Legislative Audit and an independent auditor for the South Dakota Retirement System had already signed off on the council’s books for fiscal years 2025 and 2026.
The whistleblower who wouldn’t file a report
Randall took her case to the Legislature’s Executive Board on Nov. 10, alleging she was fired after invoking state whistleblower statutes and raising concerns about transparency and pension security. She also claimed she was the target of a cyberattack.
But Assistant Attorney General Nolan Welker told the board that DCI agents had been asking Randall for a detailed complaint and supporting evidence since May or June 2025. She never provided either. After the November hearing, Sen. Pischke forwarded Randall’s Executive Board submissions to Jackley’s office, which reviewed them alongside the legislative and independent audit reports.
“Ms. Randall refused to provide any evidence or a description of her claims to this office,” Welker wrote in a letter released Friday. “She still has not done so.”
Disagreements framed as fraud
The Attorney General’s review summarized Randall’s allegations as a series of professional disputes: she disagreed with investment decisions made by colleagues, objected to fixes applied to the council’s allocation models, and challenged personnel and payroll decisions by her superiors. Randall characterized those differences as evidence of fraud or incompetence; investigators characterized them as workplace disagreements.

The probe marks the third entity with investigative authority to vet and ultimately refute claims of internal control collapse at the council. Dakota News Now noted the office examined correspondence from Randall’s legal counsel regarding a wrongful-termination claim, her letters to the Government Operations and Audit Committee, and handouts she submitted to the Executive Board.
Case closed — unless new evidence appears
Jackley’s office said the matter is closed but left the door open for any future submission of credible criminal evidence. Randall’s wrongful-termination claim and any civil proceedings remain separate from the criminal review.
“Based upon the information currently available, the Attorney General’s Office considers the matter closed,” the release said.