St. Paul High School fired football coach Austin Montoya on Friday after one season and a 2-8 record, Wisevoter reported.
The move ends a brief tenure for a coach hired in January from a pool of more than 60 applicants and leaves the program searching for its third head coach in a short span. Principal Robert Miller told Montoya the decision reflected his own impatience, adding he might regret it in a couple of years, according to the San Gabriel Valley Tribune.
The conversation that ended it
Montoya said Miller delivered the news in a meeting that caught him off guard. “I was surprised with the conversation,” Montoya told the Tribune.
“Essentially, he told me year one was a wash with the situation I came into. He told me I’m a rising star and that I will be a great coach and that he may regret the decision in a couple years. But he said he was too impatient and can’t wait. He said the couple years of seasoning that I would need to be ready he’s not willing to wait. So, they made the decision to let me go.”
What Montoya inherited
Montoya took over a roster that was young and a 2026 schedule that was already set and brutal. The previous coach, Mike Moschetti, had resigned after three seasons. His 2025 team reached the CIF Southern Section Division 5 quarterfinals despite a 4-8 record, the Whittier Daily News noted. The drop to 2-8 under Montoya looked sharp on paper, but the context was a program in transition.
A proven builder at Schurr
Before St. Paul, Montoya spent one season as head coach at Schurr High School. He guided the Spartans to a 7-4 record and the Almont League title in 2025. He had been defensive coordinator there under longtime coach Dave Ramos before earning the promotion.
Leaving Schurr was “heartbreaking,” Montoya said in January, but the St. Paul opportunity offered a bigger stage and a path to a full-time teaching position. “My wife has been the bread winner in our family and has put up with me being a coach,” he said then. “This gives me the opportunity on a bigger stage. The chance to prove myself and hopefully be a teacher full time.”
Miller’s January pitch
When he hired Montoya, Miller said the candidate checked every box. “Growing up with a Catholic education, Austin knows what we’re about and he wanted this for his kids as well,” Miller told the Tribune at the time.
“Getting to know him, just the fact that he seems like a grinder was big for me. He’s a guy who gets a lot of things done and has a great relationship with his kids. That’s what impressed me. He’s a worker and that’s what we need. He seems to embody the St. Paul tradition of hard work, effort, commitment, and those type of things. Those are important qualities in a day and age when those type of values get thrown out the window.”
The human cost
Montoya said the hardest part was not the record but the relationships. “I’m disappointed obviously,” he told the Tribune. “I built relationships with those kids. I’m more sad about those relationships and what we were building. But it’s the coaching game. This happens. You can’t be shocked about anything.”
Where the program stands
St. Paul now re-enters a competitive Southern California coaching market. Families and players await a new direction. The search will be the school’s third in recent years, and the next hire will face the same young roster and tough schedule that defined Montoya’s lone season.