Stephen Baldwin is being asked to repay $6 million after an insurance company blamed him for flooding a historic Santa Fe hotel last summer.
Westfield Insurance Company filed the negligence suit in New York Supreme Court last month, arguing the 60-year-old actor triggered a bathroom sprinkler head at the Hotel St. Francis in July 2024 and should cover the remediation bill the insurer paid to Heritage Hotels and Resorts Inc., USA Today reported.
The complaint alleges Baldwin “struck, disturbed, made contact with, or otherwise caused the activation of the fire sprinkler head located in the bathroom,” unleashing water that damaged multiple guest rooms, hallways, ceilings and walls.
Hotel staff said Baldwin admitted at the time that he hit the sprinkler while using a towel, according to court documents obtained by People. Westfield contends he failed to “exercise reasonable care in the use of the hotel room” and acted “carelessly and negligently.”
“Following the erroneous activation of the sprinkler, he immediately alerted hotel management. He was subsequently informed that hotel personnel were unable to access the maintenance room to shut off the water.”
Ross Keiser, Baldwin’s attorney, told People
Keiser called the lawsuit “frivolous” and said Baldwin disputes bearing any responsibility for the damages. On Nov. 18, Baldwin’s legal team filed a notice seeking to remove the case from New York Supreme Court and transfer it to another venue, USA Today reported. Westfield Insurance Company declined to comment on the pending litigation when contacted by People.

The property and the payout
The Hotel St. Francis, operated by Heritage Hotels and Resorts, markets itself as a historic landmark in downtown Santa Fe. Westfield said it has already advanced more than $6 million to the ownership group for “significant remediation, repair, and restoration” of the water-damaged portions of the building. The insurer is now exercising its subrogation rights to recover that outlay from Baldwin directly.
Subrogation clauses are standard in commercial property policies: once an insurer indemnifies the policyholder, it steps into the owner’s shoes to pursue any third party whose negligence may have caused the loss. If Westfield prevails, the case would reinforce the principle that a guest’s accidental damage — even without malicious intent — can trigger full financial liability when the resulting claim runs into seven figures.
Competing narratives on the water shutoff
Baldwin’s attorney asserts staff could not reach the maintenance room to cut the water, implying the extent of the damage was exacerbated by the building’s own infrastructure or emergency procedures. Westfield’s complaint does not address the shutoff delay, focusing instead on the initial activation.
Neither the Santa Fe Fire Department nor the hotel’s management company has released an incident report publicly. Without that record, a trier of fact would weigh Baldwin’s admitted contact with the sprinkler against any evidence that the hotel’s sprinkler design or maintenance access contributed to the severity of the discharge.
The Hotel St. Francis operates as Santa Fe’s oldest hotel, tracing its origins back to 1889 when it first opened as the De Vargas Hotel. Following a fire in 1922 that destroyed the original wooden structure, the building was reconstructed in 1924 with a Mission Revival exterior.
The property underwent a significant transformation in 1986 when it was remodeled and rebranded under its current name. In 2009, Heritage Hotels & Resorts acquired the site, introducing renovations that incorporated handcrafted wood furniture from local artisans and a design palette inspired by the city’s early Franciscan missionaries.
Procedural posture
The removal notice filed Nov. 18 signals Baldwin’s team will challenge venue, likely arguing the case belongs in New Mexico where the incident occurred and the property is located. If a federal court grants removal, the litigation shifts to the District of New Mexico, where local building codes and hotel maintenance records would be more accessible. A scheduling order has not yet been entered.