The deepest transaction in Young’s life was fear, and Young had been living in it the whole time he was preaching against it, Steve Young told students at BYU–Idaho on Tuesday.
The former NFL quarterback and Pro Football Hall of Famer delivered the weekly devotional, titled “The Deepest Transaction,” to 10,107 people gathered in the I-Center in Rexburg, BYU–Idaho Radio reported. He spoke for 21 minutes.
Young has spoken openly for years about the separation anxiety that followed him through two NFL MVP awards and a Super Bowl championship, chronicling it in his book QB: My Life Behind the Spiral.
Then, over the past year, the fear returned “deeper” and caught him “completely off guard,” he told the audience, according to Yahoo. “A wave of anxiety came over me unlike anything I have experienced in my adult life,” he said.
A transaction dressed in grown-up clothes
As a child, Young said, home represented safety and being away brought fear. As an adult, the objects of his worry shifted — success, relationships, faithfulness, his standing with God — but the mechanism stayed the same.
“I pursued them the way I had pursued safety as a kid: through vigilance, through worry, through the feeling that if I stayed anxious enough, I could make it happen,” he said, according to The Church News.
He realized he had been running what he called a “vending machine” — putting in worry instead of obedience, “different currency, same transaction.” The insight shook him because he had spent 15 years urging others to avoid transactional faith, what he terms “merit badge theology,” in books such as The Law of Love and The Law of Love in Action.
Young told BYU–Idaho students that the deepest transaction in his life was fear and that he had been living in it the whole time he was preaching against it.
Young cited Doctrine and Covenants 130:20–21, affirming that blessings follow obedience to divine law. The problem, he said, is the scorekeeping — the expectation that a person can guarantee a specific outcome. “That is magical thinking, and magical thinking, no matter how noble the goal, is a transaction,” he said.

Safety in Christ, not safety from storms
“Safety in Christ is not the same as a storm-free life,” he said. “God created an environment for growth, not comfort.”
He distinguished between caring and trying to control outcomes. “Can you love someone fiercely without believing your anxiety is what keeps them afloat? Can you face a hard season fully engaged, without the hidden belief that your worry earns God’s help?” Young asked, according to The Church News. “That is the shift: from fear to trust, and trust is where love leads.”
He defined “sacred surrender” as the choice to release the illusion of control and trust Jesus Christ to carry what he cannot. Surrender, he clarified, does not mean giving up responsibilities or ceasing to care. It means continuing to work, pray, and serve from a place of trust rather than fear.
Quoting John 14:27 — “Peace I leave with you, my peace I give unto you” — Young emphasized that Christ’s peace does not depend on securing a desired outcome. The Savior’s repeated command to “fear not,” he said, is not cheerleading to be tougher but an invitation to relinquish the belief that worry can purchase control.
Young chairs HGGC, a private equity firm managing over $10 billion in assets, Yahoo noted.
Fear as fuel could not carry him the full distance
Young said he had found success using fear as fuel. “I won games, I built a career, but that pattern could not carry me the full distance,” he said. He described the mindset as a false belief that worrying was caring.

Only now it was dressed up in “grown-up clothes.” His mindset was, “If I stay vigilant enough, I will be safe.”
“I tried to unravel it,” he said of his anxiety. “I sat with it, prayed through it. I talked to people that I trust. What I found shook me because it was not new.”
Young said he was glad he unearthed the truth before he dies. “Growth was the offer. Opposition was the offer.”