Study Documents First Egg-Dumping in Stilt Species, Finds Inbreeding in Hawaiian Aeʻo

“That difficulty is itself a warning sign of how inbred this population has become,” said Robert Toonen, a geneticist at the Hawaiʻi Institute of Marine Biology. A study published October 1 in Ecology and Evolution paired a decade of field observations with DNA sequencing to reveal that the Aeʻo, or Hawaiian stilt, is navigating a family life far messier and more genetically fragile than banding records alone could show

The research, led by University of Hawaiʻi at Mānoa scientists and released by University of Hawaiʻi System News, analyzed genetic material from 91 birds on Molokaʻi.

It documented the first confirmed case of “egg-dumping” in any stilt species — a female incubating an egg she did not lay — and found that only about half the family relationships researchers inferred from watching nests held up under genetic scrutiny.

Co-author Arleone Dibben-Young color-banded more than 250 stilts and tracked them weekly for ten years. Her field notes recorded three adults sharing a single nest and multiple generations defending territories together. But the DNA told a different story: several nest “siblings” were unrelated, and one mated pair may have been siblings themselves.

“In most bird studies, DNA sorts out parents, siblings and unrelated birds cleanly,” Toonen told University of Hawaiʻi System News. “Here, so many birds share so much ancestry that a parent and a sibling can look nearly identical.”

Manoa ctahr hawaiian stilts
Photo: miragenews.com

The Downlisting Context

The findings arrive months after the Aeʻo was federally downlisted from Endangered to Threatened. The state of Hawaiʻi maintains its own Endangered listing. Fewer than 1,800 stilts remain statewide, concentrated in fragmented wetland habitats.

“Downlisting is something to celebrate, but it’s not the finish line,” said Melissa Price, lead author and wildlife ecologist in the Department of Natural Resources and Environmental Management at the College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resilience. “We need to continue restoring habitat to support growing populations.”

What the Genetics Mean for Management

Afsheen Siddiqi, state waterbird biologist with the Hawaiʻi Department of Land and Natural Resources, Division of Forestry and Wildlife, said the kinship data will directly shape recovery planning. “Knowing how closely related our stilts are will help us decide where to restore wetlands and how to keep these populations growing into the future,” Siddiqi told University of Hawaiʻi System News.

The study’s eight authors — Price M, Harmon K, Toonen R, and five colleagues from the Hawaiʻi Institute of Marine Biology, the College of Tropical Agriculture and Human Resilience, and an independent scholar — argue that genetic rescue may require deliberate habitat corridors or translocations to mix isolated subpopulations.

The alternative is a slow erosion of fitness as inbreeding depression accumulates in a species that already behaves as if its entire range is one large, extended family.

Funding Secured; Next Phase Targets Statewide Sampling

Funding came from Nēnē O Molokaʻi and Hawaiʻi Sea Grant (NOAA). Researchers say the next phase is expanding genetic sampling to Oʻahu, Maui, and Kauaʻi to map the full metapopulation structure — work that will determine whether the Molokaʻi birds are an outlier or the rule.

“The federal downlisting of the Aeʻo reflects years of partnership among agencies, landowners, and communities, and studies like this one help us see what comes next,” said Afsheen Siddiqi, state waterbird biologist with the Hawaiʻi Department of Land and Natural Resources, Division of Forestry and Wildlife.