Sydney Snatch Caylen Murray at Pick 9 After Brisbane Fall Three Points Short

Sydney bid three points more than Brisbane could match, snatching academy product Caylen Murray at pick No.9 on Thursday night.

The Swans’ bid triggered a 20 per cent grand finalist loading that lifted the pick’s value from 1,355 points to 1,626. Brisbane’s available selections — picks 24 and 25 worth 1,211 points combined, plus a maximum 412‑point future deficit — totalled 1,623, leaving the premiers three points short.

The Lions had traded pick 19 down to 24 and 34 during the trade period. They expected any bid for Murray to land in the mid‑teens where they could have matched comfortably.

“I didn't realise [the bid was in] until the camera was on me, which was a bit nerve wracking. I didn't know what to expect. I didn't realise Brisbane couldn't match, but I am stoked to be a Sydney Swans player,” Murray told AFL moments after the selection.

New rules trap Brisbane

The AFL’s revamped bidding system, introduced in April, limited clubs to using only two picks to match a bid and added a 20 per cent tax for grand finalists. Brisbane had thrived under the old rules. They matched bids for Will Ashcroft (pick 2 in 2022), Levi Ashcroft (pick 5 in 2024) and Dan Annable (pick 6 in 2025) with clusters of later selections. This time the mathematics left no room to move.

Sydney list boss Chris Keane said the Swans knew the bid would stretch Brisbane to the limit. “It was probably more in the end that they couldn't match the bid,” Keane told Fox Sports. “I suppose the rules changing and the ability to only match with a couple of picks these days versus multiple in previously. We were aware it was going to be pretty tight.”

Ripple effects across the first round

Murray’s departure shuffled the board. St Kilda secured Sandringham Dragons teammates Gus Teixeira at pick 11 and Tyson Bradley at pick 16 — both rated in the Saints’ top seven. “Never seen it in probably 18 years … to have a night like that,” St Kilda recruiter Simon Dalrymple said.

Richmond added Arki Butler at pick 4 and Harry Van Hattum at pick 8, completing a three‑year run of 12 top‑31 selections. GWS traded for pick 12 and matched Melbourne’s bid on academy product Ethan Matthews at pick 6, pairing him with South Australian defender Jake Eime at pick 13.

Sydney Snatch Caylen Murray at Pick 9 After Brisbane Fall Three Points Short
Photo: Starts at 60

Murray thanks the academy that raised him

Despite the shock, Murray praised the Brisbane system that developed him over six years. “First and foremost, I just want to say thanks to the Brisbane academy and all of Brisbane for all the support. I wouldn't be in the position I am today without them,” he told Fox Sports.

“Even off the field as well they sort of developed me into the man I am today. I can't thank them enough for all their support, I really just can't thank them enough for everything.”

The Sydney Swans began as the South Melbourne Football Club on 21 March 1873 and were a founding member of the Victorian Football League in 1897. The club adopted the Swan emblem in 1933 after a journalist used the moniker following an influx of Western Australian players.

In 1982 the Swans became the first professional Australian football club to permanently relocate interstate, moving from Victoria to New South Wales and adopting the Sydney Swans name in 1983. They have won five VFL/AFL premierships, most recently in 2012, and endured a 72‑year premiership drought — the longest in the competition’s history — between 1933 and 2005.

Murray was one of four Indigenous players selected in the first round, alongside Dougie Cochrane (Port Adelaide), Cody Walker (Carlton) and Toby Krasna (Adelaide). “I'm super grateful to be a part of that, just stoked to be a part of that,” he said.