Tallahassee, Doral Reconsider ICE Deals as GOP Lawmakers Link Enforcement to Losses

After November midterms where two South Florida Republican incumbents barely survived districts they once dominated, city leaders in Tallahassee and Doral are testing whether they can unwind local ICE partnerships without losing their jobs, Florida Phoenix reported.

The tension exposes a fault line in Florida’s immigration enforcement architecture. A 2025 state law requires all 67 counties to maintain 287(g) agreements with ICE for their jails — a mandate backed by the governor’s power to suspend non-compliant commissioners. Every county has complied since April 2025. But the statute does not compel cities to sign similar deals for their police departments, and more than 30 municipalities have never done so.

Newly elected Tallahassee Mayor Jeremy Matlow told commissioners Wednesday the city never had a mandate to join the program. “The state admitted that in court that they didn’t have a mandate,” Matlow said. The commission voted unanimously to reconsider its agreement, though a final vote has not been scheduled.

“My view is, when you look at the state law, it’s pretty clear we didn’t have a mandate [to sign it].”

Jeremy Matlow, Mayor of Tallahassee

The Attorney General’s Warning

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has spent two years threatening removal for city officials who merely discuss ending their 287(g) agreements. On Thursday in Orlando, he acknowledged “rumblings” about cities contemplating withdrawal. “Here in Florida, I don’t write the law, I enforce it,” Uthmeier said.

“Local governments around the state do have Florida law statutory obligations to engage in best efforts to support the federal government in its mission. And there are penalties where they choose to do so without justification.”

Governor-elect Byron Donalds amplified the pressure hours later on X. “Florida is not a sanctuary state, and as governor, I will never let it become one,” he wrote in response to Tallahassee’s vote. “Florida cities must comply with federal and state laws — full stop.” His press team did not answer whether he will push the Legislature to extend the 287(g) mandate to cities when he takes office in January.

Doral Hits Pause, Awaits Legal Opinion

In Doral, a Miami-Dade suburb, Councilwoman Maureen Porras has tried to force a discussion on the city’s ICE partnership. Mayor Christi Fraga instead requested a formal opinion from Uthmeier’s office, delaying the debate until it arrived Thursday.

The memo from General Counsel Greg Slemp split the question in two. A city’s failure to execute a 287(g) agreement “does not by itself violate Florida law but may provide evidence of an unlawful sanctuary policy,” Slemp wrote, citing the state’s position in City of South Miami v. DeSantis.

But “choosing to rescind or terminate an executed 287(g) agreement, without sufficient justification, likely demonstrates a sanctuary policy and lack of ‘best efforts’ by a municipality, which would violate Florida Statutes.”

The South Miami Precedent

South Miami sued former Ron DeSantis last year to clarify whether municipalities must enter 287(g) agreements. A Leon County circuit judge dismissed the case as “premature” because the city faced no direct threats or penalties. Mayor Javier Fernández called the ruling “the clarity we need,” and South Miami has never signed an agreement.

Electoral Shockwaves Drive the Revolt

Representatives María Elvira Salazar (CD-27) and Mario Díaz-Balart (CD-26) won re-election, but their margins collapsed. Salazar’s 20-point victory two years ago evaporated; Díaz-Balart’s 42-point cushion vanished. Both districts are majority-Hispanic.

Fellow Republican Carlos Giménez told Fox News last week that ICE enforcement “hurt the Republicans, all right? Hurt us with Hispanics.” He made the same point on C-SPAN’s “Ceasefire” in March, linking ICE tactics to GOP losses in two special legislative elections earlier that month.

“We made great gains with Hispanics, and then we, because of the way that ICE was enforcing immigration, a lot of Hispanics say, ‘Wait, wait, that’s not what I voted for, all right?’”

“I’m telling you that what happened with ICE during the last year hurt the Republicans, all right? Hurt us with Hispanics.”

Carlos Giménez, U.S. Representative (FL-28)

Scale of the Program

Florida now runs the second-largest 287(g) deployment in the country. The Task Force Model — which deputizes local officers for civil immigration enforcement during routine patrols — operates in 279 agencies statewide, trailing only Texas, according to FWD.us. The program, created in 1996, expanded nationally after Donald Trump returned to the White House in January 2025.

Tallahassee Delays Final Vote as Doral Awaits AG Opinion

Tallahassee has not set a final vote. Doral’s council awaits its next meeting with the AG’s opinion in hand. Uthmeier has signaled enforcement readiness. Donalds enters office in January with a Legislature that may or may not close the city loophole.